Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 Foster 111

Sheetz v. Hanbest

District Court, D. Pennsylvania

Decided March 21, 1874

District Court, D. Pennsylvania · decided 1874-03-21

<p>The act of 1869 disqualifies a party as a witness when the other party is dead, although he would not have been disqualified prior to that act.</p> <p>Briggs, J., and Thayer, J., concurring; .Hare, P. J., and Mitchell, J., dissenting.</p>

Decided 1874-03-21

Hare, P. J., and Mitchell, J.,

¶1dissenting.

¶2The act of 1869 is entirely an enabling act. The proviso excepis from the operation of the act certain cases, as to which the law remains as it was before the passage of the statute. It is conceded that the witness would have been competent at common law; Ferree v. Thompson, 2 P. F. S. 353 ; and we are of opinion that nothing in the act disqualifies him. There is no decision of the supreme^court reported, in which any witness has been held incompetent who would have been competent before the act of 1869.

/2/foster/111 · .json · Public domain