Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 Johns. 100

Welsh v. Hill

New York Supreme Court

Decided November 15, 1806

New York Supreme Court · decided 1806-11-15

The defendant obtained a'n order from a judge, at his chambers, for the plaintiff to show cause why the defendant should not be discharged on filing common bail. — - The plaintiff resided at Havanna.

Decided 1806-11-15

Per Curiam.

¶1The affidavit of Post, the correspondent of the house in England, is not positive. He does not swear that he believes any thing due to the plaintiff.—

¶2These affidavits are insufficient, and the defendant must be discharged on filing common bail. As to receiving counter affidavits in such cases, the practice was settled in the case of Clason v. Lyde, in April term, 1801, where the court decided, that a judge at his chambers might, in his discretion, admit or refuse counter affidavits, according to circumstances. Where the plaintiff swears positively to a debt, it would be improper to receive them.

¶3Rule granted.

/2/johns/100 · .json · Public domain