Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 Johns. 201

Ramchander v. Hammond

New York Supreme Court

Decided February 15, 1807

New York Supreme Court · decided 1807-02-15

This was an action on a promissory note, dated at Calcutta, the 23d November, 1797, by the defendant to plaintiff, a native of India, and inhabitant of Calcutta, for four thousand and forty rupees, payable twelve months after date, with interest, at the rate of twenty per cent, per annum. The defendant pleaded non assumpsit and non assumpsit infra sex amos.

Decided 1807-02-15

Per Curiam.

¶1Our statute of limitations excepts “ actions which concern the trade of merchandise between merchants.” These words are not so broad as to warrant' a departure from the adjudications which have been made on the English act. These words, like those of the statute of James, must be confined to actions on open or current accounts; they do no not extend to accounts stated. It must be a direct concern of trade; liquidated demands, or bills and notes, which are only traced up to the trade of merchandise, are too remote to come within this description. To adopt the construction contended for on the part of the plaintiff, might be found very in*203convenient, and the phraseology of the act does not au-thorise us to suppose, that the framers of it intended so important an alteration. The demurrer must, therefore, be considered as well taken; but the plaintiff has leave to withdraw his replication, or amend, on pa yment of costs, (a)

¶2Judgment for the defendant.

¶3 Vide 2 Saund. 124. 5 Cranch, 15, and 14 John. Rep. 479. where this doctrine is commented upon, and fully sustained.

¶4The exceptions in favour of merchants in the statute of limitations of Virginia, applies as well to actions of assumpsit as to actions of account. 6 Cranch, 15. Where an account has been of long standing, and the last item in it entered more than six years, yet if there has not been an actual settlement, it is to be considered a running acconnt, and not barred by the statute, Franklin v. Camp, 1 Cox, 196.

/2/johns/201 · .json · Public domain