<p>
Error from Atchison Cmmt/y.
</p> <p>A statement of the facts of the case appears in the opinion of the Court.</p> <p>•1st.’ The Court erred in not confirming the sale made to Challis of the N£ of lot 9 in block 19.</p> <p>The proceedings under the order of sale are all regular. This is admitted. The Court then could only confirm or set aside the sale. See code, Sec. 449.</p> <p>2d. The Court erred in admitting the testimony offered by the defendants in error. It was trying the title to the premises on a motion to confirm a sale. The Court could not thus try this title. The party is entitled to a jury o'n the trial of title of real estate.</p> <p>In this case the Court, notwithstanding the objections of the plaintiff in error, tried the title to the land in controversy, giving the plaintiff in error no chance to be heard before a jury. Code, Sec. 214.</p> <p>The Court could hear only such testimony as proved or disproved the legality of the sale. Code, Sec. 449.</p> <p>The Court erred in ordering a deed to be made to Wise & Crookham.</p> <p>The subject matter of the motion was res adjuddcata. The judgment of Challiss v. Headley & Carr and Wise & Crookham, enjoined Wise & Crookham from setting up or claiming any interest in or to the premises in controversy.</p> <p>The right of Wise & Crookham in the premises, had been' passed upon and settled, and so remains till that judgment is set aside or reversed.</p> <p>The following authorities settle this question in favor of the plaintiff in error:</p> <p>2 Parsons on Contracts, 234; Grant v. Pamsey, 7, O. S. P., 157; Simmons v. Dunn, 4 O. S. P., 680; 2d Phil, Ev., (3d Ed. 1849,) 4-5-9-13; Phil. Ev. Vol. 4, Note 13, p. 13, ei seq.; Gardner v. Buckhall, 3d Cow. 120; Broom’s Legal Maxims, 243-131; Doty v. Brown, ComstocFs P., Vol. 4, 71; Smith’s Leading Cases, (esiopple by record, 667,) and cases cited; Eversol v. Plank, 17 O. P., 61; George v. Gillespie, :1 Iowa, 421; Chase v. Walker, 20 Pep., 555; 10 O. P. 300; 9 O. P., 67; Young v. Black, 7 Cranch, 565; Hites v. Enos, 13 O. S. R., Mss.</p> <p>Plaintiff was not entitled to confirmation asked for.</p> <p>I. lie had no legal judgment against Headley & Carr.</p> <p>II. Defendants were not legally notified of his suit, being misled by the summons, 2d, There was no prayer for relief against them in plaintiff’s petition. Nash, Note B and D, Addenda, p. 781; Seney, p. 78, Note B and C\ Nash,p. 54; Civil Code, Sec. 94, p. 139.</p> <p>III. Defendants were not notified of appraisement made by plaintiff, and hence, the sale was illegal as to them. Chap. 172, y>.’773; 2 O. S. R., 406.</p> <p>IY. After the property had been sold to defendants, it could not be sold to plaintiff, and hence there was no sale to confirm.</p> <p>But one sale of same property could be made upon process against same defendants. Nash, 607; 5 O. P., 522.</p> <p>Plaintiffs execution was void because it did not follow judgment. Nash, p. 589; see Transcript,p. 9-</p> <p>
Defendantd confirmation legal.
</p> <p>He had a valid judgment. His lien became fixed by-levy of execution several months before plaintiffs mortgage, and having no interest in said land, except such as might remain after defendants lien was satisfied. See Statute, p. 862, See. M3 Cimil Oode,p. 194.</p> <p>Their sale was regular. Plaintiffs lien being subsequent to defendants said levy, was not entitled to notice of appraisement.</p> <p>Defendants lien not foreclosed by plaintiff, 1st. Because not notified of suit. 2d. Because it was a prior right and not affected by proceedings upon rights accruing subsequently. Civil Code, See. 426. See Smey, 360, Note G\ 17 O. B., 578; 14 O. B., 318; 16 O. B., 533.</p> <p>Only when judgment becomes dormant, does lien cease. Seney, 342, Note B; 10 O. B., 403.</p> <p>The Court did right in examining the proceedings to ascertain if there was a legal foundation for the execution upon which the sale was made. If not, no sale was made,</p> <p>If the Court could not go behind the Sheriff’s return, plaintiff could not show that defendant was foreclosed.</p> <p>Defendant having an interest in the property was entitled to be heard on plaintiffs motion to confirm.</p> <p>It is a principle well settled, that a Court in reviewing errors, will go back to the first error committed, and if upon examination it be found that the party complaining has not been injured, the judgment will not be disturbed.</p> <p>The plaintiff not having a legal .judgment’, the defendant having had no notice of appraisement, and such property not having been legally sold ' on plaintiffs process, same being on a lien subsequent to that of another process to sell at same time, in hands of Sheriff, plaintiff could not be entitled to a deed, and hence his rights were not affected by the judgment of the Court below.</p> <p>Judgment below should be affirmed.</p>