Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 Miles 203

Oakford v. Johnson

Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Philadelphia County · decided 1838-04-23

THIS was an action brought by Charles Oakford against Henry Johnson, to March term, 1838, No. 633, on a promissory note in the following words : “ Philadelphia, 8th Bee, 183?, “ Three months after date, I promise to pay to A. K. Fahne-stock, or order, one hundred dollars, without defalcation, for value received. (Signed) J. C. Snyder.

Decided 1838-04-23

¶1The opinion of the court wras delivered by

Pettit, President.—

¶2According to the allegation of the affidavit of defence, Snyder being charged by Fahnestock with a larceny, and being under arrest, compounded the offence; the note in question being part of the inducement to the arrangement. The consideration being clearly illegal, no suit on the note could be sustained between the original parties. The note was sent by Fahnestock the payee, to the present plaintiff, to be applied, when collected, to the payment of a pre-existing debt. The plaintiff did not give any new consideration for the note. He neither gave *205up the old debt, nor parted with any security for it, nor gave time in regard to it. He is then, in privity with the original holder, and may be affected by any defence which would be available between the original parties. This disposition of the case, upon the grounds stated in the affidavit of defence, renders it unnecessary to consider the question, whether, under the circumstances, a bona fide holder for value could or could not recover on the note.

¶3Rule discharged.

/2/miles/203 · .json · Public domain