Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 Miss. 100

Babcock v. Scott

Mississippi Supreme Court

Decided July 15, 1834

Mississippi Supreme Court · decided 1834-07-15

BABCOCK, Gardner & Co. commenced an action upon the case in assumpsit in the circuit court of Yazoo county, against Thomas S. Scott and J. Robinson. To the declaration the defendant, Scott, pleaded non assumpsit, upon which there was issue.

Decided 1834-07-15

Mr. Justice Smith

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2I am not aware that it has ever been holden, that a refusal of a judge to grant a continuance is error. This power is committed solely to the discretion of the judge. See Woods & Broms v. Young, 4 Cranch, 237; Marine Insurance Company of Alexandria v. Hodgson, 6 Cranch, 206.

¶3The defect pleaded in abatement by Robinson, existed in the declaration, though not apparent upon the face of it. The prayer of judgment, therefore, is proper, and no valid objection exists to it on that ground.

¶4But the party pleading in abatement has not made defence. This is strictly a technical objection, and founded upon the artificial reasons which sustain the science of special pleading. De-fence, either half or whole, is required to be made before plea entered; which is a resistance or denial of the demand of the writ.

¶5' .In all pleas which admit the jurisdiction of the court, to which class the one under consideration belongs, full defence is required. See Gould’s Pleadings, c. ii, ss. 6 and 10. And so long as the principles of special pleading are pursued, the defect here pointed out will form ground of special demurrer.

¶6Pleas in abatement, as they prevent an examination into the merits of a cause, and defeat the writ, but do not bar the right of action, are unfavorably regarded by the courts. 2 Saunders, 209; 13 Gould’s Pleadings, c. iii, s. 58. And any objections to form or substance will be entertained against them. I am, therefore, clear that the court, in sustaining the demurrer for the first cause assigned, did not err.

¶7Judgment must be affirmed.

/2/miss/100 · .json · Public domain