Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 Miss. 19

Young v. Englehard

Mississippi Supreme Court

Decided January 15, 1834

Mississippi Supreme Court · decided 1834-01-15

This was an action of assumpsit, commenced by Young against Englehard and Silverberg in the circuit court of Lawrence county. In that court a verdict was rendered in favor of Young.

Error assigned · Decided 1834-01-15

Mr. Chief Justice Shahkev

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2This is an appeal from the circuit court of Lawrence county. The jury found for the plaintiff below more than he was entitled *20to upon the evidence, and- on this account the defendants moved the court for a new trial. The plaintiff, before the motion was decided, came into court and entered a remittitur for the excess found, and after this entry the court refused the motion for a new trial, and thereon the defendants appealed.

¶3A motion for a new trial is always directed to the sound discretion of the court under the evidence in, the case.

¶4The record in this case shows that the remittitur was to the full amount of the excess, as shown by the testimony relied on by the defendants in support of their motion. If, then, it was clear to the court that the verdict, after deducting the amount of the remittitur, was right and supported by the testimony, it was then clearly a matter within the discretion of the court below, and we think they did not err in refusing the motion.

¶5Judgment below affirmed.

/2/miss/19 · .json · Public domain