Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 N.C. 446

State v. Landreth

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided January 15, 1816

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1816-01-15

The defendant was indicted for malicious mischief, in stabbing with a butcher’s knife, a mare the property of Young; but from the circumstances disclosed in the evidence, Henderson, J. before whom the cause was tried, was inclined to doubt whether the facts proved constituted the crime.

Decided 1816-01-15

Taylor, C. J.

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court:

¶2We do not think that the facts found in this case, bring the offence within the common law notion of malicious mischief. That seems to be confined to those cases, where the act is done in a spirit of wanton malignity, without provocation or excuse, and under circumstances which bespeak a mind prompt and disposed to the commission of mischief. It is essential, says Blackstone, to the commission of this offence, that it must be done out of a spirit of wanton cruelty, or black and diabolical revenge. 4 Bl. 244.

¶3The conduct of the defendant was certainly highly reprehensible and barbarous, yet it was prompted by the sudden resentment of an injury, which is calculated, in no slight degree, to awaken passion; and there is a difference which *447every one must feel, between an act committed under such circumstances, and one where the party, goes off his own, land in pursuit of an animal which had done him no injury, for the sake of exercising cruelty, or perpetrating wanton mischief.—Judgment for the defendant.

/2/nc/446 · .json · Public domain