Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 N.J.L. 420

Den ex dem. Mackey v. Mackey

Sussex County Superior Court

Decided November 15, 1807

Sussex County Superior Court · decided 1807-11-15

The title was admitted to be in the father of the lessors of the plaintiff. The lessor derived title from his father. It appeared in evidence, that the father about fifteen years ago, put the defendant, who was his brother, into possession.

Decided 1807-11-15

[*«] Pennington, J.

¶1— It is certainly a hard case to turn a man out of possession, circumstanced like the defendant, at any season of the year, and saddle him with a bill of cost without notice; he went into [308] possession by the consent of the owner, has continued in it fifteen years, improving the premises, under a reasonable expectation that he was to have it for life. Some of the cases requiring notice have gone on the ground of reservation of rent; but I do not know that this is the exclusive rule; and if it is, may not the improvement put on the premises come in place of the rent as being equally valuable.

¶2On the whole, I think some notice should be given; that not being done, the plaintiff must be called.

¶3Nonsuit.

¶4Cited in Den, Bray, v. McShane, 1 Gr. 35; Den, McEowen, v. Drake, 2 Gr. 533; Den, Snowhill, v. Snowhill, 3 Zab. 447

¶5Contra, Cox v. Baird, 6 Halst. 105.

¶6Note. — The plaintiff’s counsel wished the case reserved; but it hath not since been heard of.

/2/njl/420 · .json · Public domain