Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 N.Y.S. 737

Stark v. McClosky

City of New York Municipal Court

Decided November 30, 1888

City of New York Municipal Court · decided 1888-11-30

Oil exceptions from trial term. Action by J. Emery Stark against Charles McClosky for the price of goods sold and delivered. After verdict for plaintiff, defendant moves for a new7 trial on exceptions which were ordered to be heard in the first instance at the general term.

Decided 1888-11-30

Browne, J.

¶1The action is for a balance claimed to be due for goods sold and delivered. The answer put in issue every allegation of the complaint. An issue in the case was whether the contract of sale was in fact made with plaintiff in his individual capacity or as the representative of the Central Moulding & Lumber Company. The defendant requested to be permitted to give testimony showing that the plaintiff was the manager of the company at the time of the transaction referred to in the complaint, and that the transaction was in fact one with the company; and that, if there was any liability on the part of the defendant, (which is denied, the defendant claiming payment,) it was to the company. The justice declined to receive the evidence. The defendant thereupon excepted.

¶2The ruling was error. The exception w7ill be sustained; the verdict in favor of the plaintiff will be set aside; and a new trial ordered, with costs to abide the event.

¶3McAdah, C. J., and Ehrlich, J., concur.

/2/nys/737 · .json · Public domain