Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 Posey 323

Fant v. Brannin

Texas Commission of Appeals

Decided July 1, 1885

Texas Commission of Appeals · decided 1885-07-01

Opinion by Watts, J. ■ Statement.— Appellees brought trespass to try title against appellant to recover four several tracts of land. Appellant answered by general demurrer and general denial,-and relied upon a tax deed for title. Upon the trial the court excluded the tax deed as muniment of title.

Decided 1885-07-01

¶1Opinion.— In this case appellant claims through a tax deed executed by Alex. Coker, as tax collector of Live Oak county, to R H. Brown, for four several tracts of land described in the petition.

¶2The deed recites that the sale was made to pay the delinquent tax assessed upon the 'land against A. C. and J. S. Brannin, for the year 1875.

¶3This sale was made upon the certificate of the comptroller, under the. act approved August 19, 1876. General Laws 1876, p. 255. Aside from the certificate of comptroller, there was no evidence adduced tending to show that any assessment of the tax had been made upon the land.

¶4It is incumbent upon a party claiming under a tax deed to establish, by evidence other than the recitals in the deed, a substantial compliance with the statute, and a compliance with the prerequisites authorizing the sale, including a valid assessment.- Here it does not appear when or by whom, the assessment was made, or by what authority, or how *324evidenced. Besides the sale was made in gross; that is, the four several tracts of land, aggregating one thousand two hundred and eighty acres, were sold in gross for the sum of $8.50, and, as this affirmatively appears upon the face of the deed, it seems clear, for that reason, the deed must be considered as void, Montgomery v. Birge, 31 Ark., 491; Long v. Wolf, 25 Kan., 523; Byam v. Cook, 21 Iowa, 392. In our opinion the court did not err in excluding tax deed.

¶5Mor was there ahy error in admitting the certified copy of the decree of the district court of Jack county partitioning the estate of J. W. Owen, deceased, in 1882.

¶6The tax deed under which appellant claimed only purported to convey two of these tracts.

¶7Aeeirmed.

/2/posey/323 · .json · Public domain