Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 Stew. & P. 141

Castleberry v. Pearce

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided January 15, 1832

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1832-01-15

This was an action of trespass, brought to recover damages for a malicious prosecution. The declaration was filed at the fall term, 1828, of the Circuit court of St. Clair county. At the Spring term, 1829, the cause was continued, on the affidavit of the defendant. At the fall term, 1829, it was continued on the special affidavit of the defendant.

Decided 1832-01-15

Per curiam.

¶1From several circumstances, we are authorised to infer, that an issue in fact, going to the merits of the action, had been found by the pleadings, and since lost from the record; or that the parties consented to go to trial as on an issue. The record shews that the jury were sworn to try the issue joined. And the jury in their verdict, set out that they find the issue in favor of the plaintiff. To conclude that there had been no issue, would be falsifying the record.

¶2Again, the circumstance of the cause having been continued on the affidavit of the defendant, three several times, affords strong grounds to believe that the pleadings had been made up.

¶3The fact, that a want of an issue was not assigned as a ground for the arrest of the judgment, in the court below, affords a further, and a .strong presumption, that there was an issue at the time the motion was entered.

¶4There'is nothing in the second assignment.

¶5The judgment must be affirmed.

/2/stewp/141 · .json · Public domain