majority">Dillon, J.

„ competent evi ence. The record shows that five witnesses, in addition to the said Philomela, gave competent evidence before the grand jury, and sufficient, even if hers was excluded, to justify and even require £bem £n(q a bill. To sustain the ruling of the court, the defendant’s attorney cites us to subdivision 4 of section 4691 of the Revision, which provides that the indictment shall be set aside “ when any person other than the grand jurors was present before the grand jury during the investigation of the charge, except as required or permitted by law.”

It is not claimed that the wife “ was present before the grand jury during the investigation of the charge ” against the indictees, except when being examined as a witness.

But the objection is, that she was present as a witness; and the argument to support it is, that being the wife of one of the defendants on a joint charge and indictment, she was incompetent as a witness (Rev., § 3983); that being incompetent as against her husband, she is likewise incompetent as against any co-defendant (1 Greenl. Ev., §§ 334, 335); that from the nature of the charge she cannot testify against her daughter, without at the same time implicating her husband; that being for these reasons incompetent as a witness, she was “ neither required or permitted by law ” to be present during the investigation before the grand jury. It is not necessary to decide *510whether the wife is a competent witness against her husband or the daughter. Even if it be admitted that she is not, still this constitutes no ground for setting aside the indictment. The section of the Revision cited (4691, sub-div. 4), has no reference to such a case.

Its object is to exclude outsiders or spectators from, the grand j ury room.

Whether witnesses are competent is of often a very difficult question of law, and to hold that if the grand jury, in the course of their investigation, happen to examine an incompetent witness, that this will have the effect to vitiate their finding, is going a step further than we are prepared to take. The motion of the daughter to set aside the indictment should have been overruled.

Reversed.

Citation profile

How this case has been treated — in progress