Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

20 La. 511

Johnson v. Gennisson

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided June 15, 1868

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1868-06-15

<p>An appeal taken from a judgment, not signed by the District Judge, will be dismissed 'x proprio motu,</p>

Relies on Commonwealth v. New York · Pennsylvania R. Co. v. Stern & Spiegel

Decided 1868-06-15

Labatjve, J.

¶1E. M. Ivens is appellant from a judgment, rendered against him as surety on an appeal bond.

¶2The record shows that the judgment appealed from was not signed.

¶3It is now well-settled by our jurisprudence, that no i.ppeal lies from a judgment before it is signed; in such a case the judgment is inchoate, and the appeal premature. O. P., Arts. 546, 555, 558. IN. S., 89. 7 L. 513. 9 L. 275. 18 L. 30. 4 R. 451. 9 A. 42. 12 A. 756. 19 A. 291.

¶4So long as a judgment is not signed, a motion for a new trial may be made and allowed. 5 N. S. 320. 4 R. 152.

¶5Under these authorities, it is considered that the judgment is pending below, and although no motion have been made to dismiss the appeal, we consider that we have no jurisdiction to revise the judgment, and that we are bound ex proprio motu, to dismiss the appeal.

¶6.Appeal dismissed, at appellant’s costs.

/20/la/511 · .json · Public domain