Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

20 Mich. 327

Chope v. Lorman

Michigan Supreme Court

Decided May 3, 1870

Michigan Supreme Court · decided 1870-05-03

This was an action of trespass brought by Chas. A. Lorman against Edward Chope, Frederick L. Seitz, Henry Seitz and Michael Staueh, for entering upon the premises of the plaintiff and cutting and carrying away a thousand tons of ice.

Decided 1870-05-03

Per Curiam.

¶1The Court below allowed the jury to give to the Benson agreement such weight, by way of admission, as they thought it deserved. But it cannot operate by way of estoppel here. Estoppels must be mutual, and plaintiffs in error do not claim under the lease or agreement in question, and cannot, therefore, set up any estoppel under it against Lorman. The instrument is not necessarily inconsistent with his private rights, and while, as against Benson and his grantees, he could not impeach the privileges secured by the lease, no one else could question his title by reason of anything in that arrangement.

¶2Judgment must be affirmed with costs.

/20/mich/327 · .json · Public domain