¶1
¶2
¶3 The judgment is reversed, and the cause is remanded.
¶4 Reversed and remanded.
200 Ala. 4
75 So 316
Decided April 26, 1917
Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1917-04-26
<p>1. Trial <&wkey;139(l) — Question eor Jury — Motion to Exclude Evidence.</p> <p>Where there is even a modicum of legal evidence before the jury, a motion to exclude all of plaintiff’s evidence is improper.</p> <p>[Ed. Note. — For other cases, see Trial, Cent. Dig. §§ 332, 333, 338-341.] (</p> <p>2. Evidence <&wkey;78 — Presumptions — Operation and Eeeect — Presumption Against Spoliator.</p> <p>In statutory ejectment, plaintiff’s evidence tending to show that the conveyance sustaining his action was in form a deed, bearing certain signatures, that it was a deed, and had been delivered to him, and that he was named as grantee therein, etc., together with evidence that defendant had purposely destroyed or caused to be destroyed such instrument, made a prima facie case, since the rule of presumption against the spoliator was applicable.</p> <p>[Ed. Note. — Eor other cases, see Evidence, Cent. Dig. §§ 98, 100.]</p> <p>3. Evidence <&wkey;78 — Presumption — Spoliation oe Evidence.</p> <p>Against a party who has purposely and wrongfully destroyed documentary evidence that the spoliator knows is pertinent and material to the interest of his opponent, whether an action is then pending- or not, a rebuttable presumption arises unfavorable to the spoliator, such rule being the result of common experience and judgment that men will not ordinarily destroy evidence beneficial to themselves, and that it is proper to attribute to the spoliator a prima facie knowledge on his part that the truth manifested by the instrument would operate against him.</p> <p><&wkey;J?or other oases see same topic and KEY-NUMBER in all Key-Numbered Digests and Indexes</p> <p>[Ed. Note. — For other cases, see Evidence, Cent. Dig. §§ 98, 100.]</p> <p>4. Evidence <&wkey;78 —Presumption —Spoliation oe Evidence.</p> <p>The measure and quality of the evidence descriptive of the instrument necessary to afford the bases for an application of the presumption against the spoliator are that there should be presented, by him whose right or interest is supposed to be prejudiced by the destruction of the instrument, evidence of a general character, reasonably calculated to invite the conclusion that an instrument of the type in question existed, and that it was purposely destroyed or caused to be destroyed by the alleged spoliator, and strict proof of the contents of such an instrument, so destroyed, is not required, for if a higher degree of proof were to be exacted, the rule of the maxim would be without practical service.</p> <p>[Ed. Note. — For other cases, see Evidence, Cent. Dig. §§ 98, 109.]</p> <p>5. Ejectment i&wkey;95(3) — Burden oe Prooe.</p> <p>Where plaintiff in statutory ejectment showed he was one of the heirs at law of his parents and had been excluded from the enjoyment of the common inheritance by his defendant brother, he made a prima facie showing of his tenancy in common, throwing the burden on defendant to bring- forward evidence of a conveyance to him to justify such exclusion.</p> <p>[K'd. Note. — For other eases, see Ejectment, Cent. Dig. § 284.]</p> <p><§=»For other cases see same topic and KEY-NUMBER in all Key-Numfcered Digests and Indexes»</p>
Relies on Athey v. Tennessee Coal, Iron & Railway Co. · McCray v. Sharpe · In Matter of the Estate of Lambie v. McMillan (Mich. 10-2-1893)
Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know
Reversed and remanded · Decided 1917-04-26
Cited by 13 later decisions — most recently August 2004
13 state decisions
Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.
View the full empirical analysis of this case →
¶1
¶2
¶3 The judgment is reversed, and the cause is remanded.
¶4 Reversed and remanded.