Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

200 N.C. 497

157 S.E 793

Morehead v. . Montague

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided March 25, 1931

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1931-03-25

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently December 1949

2 state decisions

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“So, it has been held that a deed conveying land to a married woman and her heirs `by her present husband' vests an estate in fee”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Whitley v. . Arenson

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1931-03-25

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

AdaMs, J.

¶1 Our disposition of the present appeal is dependent upon the interpretation of the deed executed by J. K. Todd on 17 December, 1897. If his deed conveyed to Della Todd, his wife, a title in fee, the deed which he and his wife executed and delivered to E. R. Gulley on 25 November, 1903, likewise conveyed the fee,, and not merely an estate for her life.

¶2 A conveyance of land “to Della Todd during her lifetime and at her death to the heirs of her body,” without additional words, would transfer the fee. Foley v. Ivey, 193 N. C., 453; Tyson v. Sinclair, 138 N. C., 23; Leathers v. Gray, 101 N. C., 162. What is the effect of the qualifying words, “begotten by J. K. Todd” ?

¶3 In Thompson v. Crump, 138 N. C., 32, this Court held that a devise of land “to my son James for and during his life, and after his death to his' lawful heirs, born of his wife,” was not within the rule in Shel-letfs case, the words “born of his wife” qualifying the explaining phrase “his lawful heirs,” so as to confine the remainder to the children of his wife and to prevent the operation of the rule. The decision followed Dawson v. Quinnerly, 118 N. C., 188. But in Sessoms v. Sessoms, 144 N. C., 121, the Court disapproved the ruling in these cases and in Bird v. Gilliam, 121 N. C., 326, and held that the first devisee takes an estate in fee simple if the terms of the devise carry the entire estate in fee tail, whether general or special. So it has been held that a deed conveying land to a married woman and her heirs “by her present husband” vests an estate in fee. Jones v. Raysdale, 141 N. C., 200; Paul v. Paul, 199 N. C., 522. Under the former law the estate would have been a fee tail special, but our statute provides that every person seized of an estate tail shall be deemed to be seized thereof in fee simple. C. S., 1734. The rule in question applies where there is a gift to a husband with remainder to the heirs of his body by his present wife, or to a wife with remainder to the heirs of her body by her present husband. In the first instance the heirs are to be ascertained upon the death of the husband; in the latter upon the death of the wife. I Tiffany on Real Property, 532, sec. 148. It will be noted that the limitation over was defeated and the estate became absolute upon the birth of the son, Jack Marlan Todd. Radford v. Rose, 178 N. C., 288. Judgment

¶4 Affirmed.

/200/nc/497 · .json · Public domain