Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2000 Ohio 424

State ex rel. Piotrowski v. Indus. Comm.

Ohio Supreme Court

Decided May 31, 2000

Ohio Supreme Court · decided 2000-05-31

Workers' compensation—Industrial Commission's denial of change of election by claimant not an abuse of discretion, when.

Relies on State ex rel. Berger v. McMonagle · 88 Ohio St. 3d 556 - State ex rel. Piotrowski v. Industrial Commission

Decided 2000-05-31

[This opinion has been published in Ohio Official Reports at 
88 Ohio St.3d 556
.]




THE STATE EX REL. PIOTROWSKI, APPELLANT, v. INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION OF
                               OHIO ET AL., APPELLEES.
       [Cite as State ex rel. Piotrowski v. Indus. Comm., 
2000-Ohio-424
.]
Workers’ compensation—Industrial Commission’s denial of change of election by
        claimant not an abuse of discretion, when.
        (No. 98-2519—Submitted April 26, 2000—Decided May 31, 2000.)
  APPEAL from the Court of Appeals for Franklin County, No. 97APD08-1019.
                                  __________________
        {¶ 1} Appellant-claimant, Virginia Piotrowski, was injured in an industrial
accident in 1986, and a workers’ compensation claim was allowed for “laceration
right forearm; epineurolysis of the radial nerve.” An additional allowance for
“muscle hypertrophy of the flexor carpi ulnaris near the right elbow” was thereafter
ordered in the claim. Claimant initially missed one month of work before returning
to light duty work with her employer, appellee, Kennecott Corporation, Chase
Brass & Copper Company (“Kennecott”). The plant closed in 1990, and claimant
secured work elsewhere.
        {¶ 2} Claimant sought a determination of her percentage of permanent
partial disability, and, on or about July 1989, appellee Industrial Commission of
Ohio found a fifteen percent permanent partial disability (“PPD”) and awarded
compensation. Given the option of seeking payment as impaired earning capacity
(“IEC”) benefits pursuant to former R.C. 4123.57(A) or receiving it as a lump sum
permanent partial disability award under former R.C. 4123.57(B), claimant elected
the latter. Three and one-half years later, claimant received a four percent increase
in her PPD. She also received that award under former R.C. 4123.57(B).
        {¶ 3} In August 1995, claimant applied to reactivate her claim. In her
application, she requested “temporary partial,” i.e., IEC benefits. Payment of such
                             SUPREME COURT OF OHIO




benefits first required, however, the commission’s permission to change election.
Claimant requested this permission on January 4, 1996.
       {¶ 4} A district hearing officer (“DHO”) ruled on claimant’s reactivation
request, and also authorized a change of election. On April 19, 1996, a staff hearing
officer (“SHO”) vacated the DHO order after finding “no legal authority which
indicates that ‘unforeseen circumstances’ contemplates changes in the local
economy as opposed to changes in physical condition.”
       {¶ 5} Claimant responded with two filings. She first appealed the SHO
order. She then moved that the appeal be postponed until she filed for—and the
commission ruled on—the additional allowance of certain conditions. Claimant,
however, delayed in moving for additional allowance, and the commission, in the
meantime, refused further appeal of the April 19, 1996 order.
       {¶ 6} Claimant formally sought an additional allowance on June 25, 1996.
On July 19, 1996, a DHO ruled on all of claimant’s outstanding motions. The claim
was additionally allowed for “complex regional pain syndrome, type I; reflex
sympathetic dystrophy, right arm.” A change of election was denied because the
issue was deemed “res judicata as the [SHO] order dated 04-19-96 adjudicated such
issue.” Claimant did not appeal. Kennecott, however, appealed the additional
allowance.
       {¶ 7} On October 22, 1996, an SHO affirmed the DHO’s order in its
entirety. Although Kennecott appealed, claimant still declined to do the same.
Instead, she responded with a third motion seeking a change of election.
       {¶ 8} On November 21, 1996, further appeal of the October 22, 1996 order
was refused. On March 31, 1997, claimant’s third election motion was denied,
again on res judicata grounds, the DHO noting claimant’s failure to appeal the July
19, 1996 order. Claimant finally appealed the March 31, 1997 order, but the order
was administratively affirmed.




                                         2
                                January Term, 2000




       {¶ 9} Claimant filed a complaint in mandamus in the Court of Appeals for
Franklin County, asserting that the commission abused its discretion in denying her
a change of election. The court of appeals denied relief, after finding that claimant
had an adequate remedy in the ordinary course of law, via administrative appeal,
that she did not pursue.
       {¶ 10} This cause is now before this court upon an appeal as of right.
                              __________________
       Ticktin, Baron, Koepper & Co., L.P.A., and Harold Ticktin, for appellant.
       Betty D. Montgomery, Attorney General, and Gerald H. Waterman,
Assistant Attorney General, for appellee Industrial Commission.
       Rademaker, Matty, McClelland & Greve and Kirk R. Henrikson, for
appellee Kennecott Corporation.
                              __________________
       Per Curiam.
       {¶ 11} Mandamus cannot issue when there is a plain and adequate remedy
in the ordinary course of law. State ex rel. Berger v. McMonagle (1983), 
6 Ohio St.3d 28
, 6 OBR 50, 
451 N.E.2d 225
. In this case, claimant had numerous
opportunities to appeal orders denying her a change of election. Instead, she
responded by repeatedly refiling the same motion, which only complicated further
an already convoluted administrative path.
       {¶ 12} Accordingly, we affirm the judgment of the court of appeals.
                                                                Judgment affirmed.
       MOYER, C.J., DOUGLAS, RESNICK, F.E. SWEENEY, PFEIFER, COOK and
LUNDBERG STRATTON, JJ., concur.
                              __________________




                                         3

/2000/ohio/424 · .json · Public domain