Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2000 Ohio 97

Akron Bar Assn. v. Bodnar

Ohio Supreme Court

Decided December 13, 2000

Ohio Supreme Court · decided 2000-12-13

Attorneys at law—Misconduct—Permanent disbarment—Engaging in illegal conduct involving moral turpitude—Engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation—Engaging in conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice—Engaging in conduct adversely reflecting on fitness to practice law—Failing to cooperate in an investigation of a complaint—Previous stayed six-month suspension.

Relies on 84 Ohio St. 3d 372 - Akron Bar Ass'n. v. Bodnar · Akron Bar Ass'n v. Bodnar

Decided 2000-12-13

[This opinion has been published in Ohio Official Reports at 
90 Ohio St.3d 399
.]




                        AKRON BAR ASSOCIATION v. BODNAR.
                [Cite as Akron Bar Assn. v. Bodnar, 
2000-Ohio-97
.]
Attorneys at law—Misconduct—Permanent disbarment—Engaging in illegal
        conduct involving moral turpitude—Engaging in conduct involving
        dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation—Engaging in conduct
        prejudicial to the administration of justice—Engaging in conduct
        adversely reflecting on fitness to practice law—Failing to cooperate in an
        investigation of a complaint—Previous stayed six-month suspension.
   (No. 00-1098—Submitted August 22, 2000—Decided December 13, 2000.)
    ON CERTIFIED REPORT by the Board of Commissioners on Grievances and
                     Discipline of the Supreme Court, No. 99-41.
                                  __________________
        {¶ 1} On August 9, 1999, relator, Akron Bar Association, filed a complaint
against respondent, Andrew P. Bodnar, Jr. of Akron, Ohio, Attorney 
Registration No. 0032329,
 for allegedly violating DR 1-102(A)(3) (engaging in illegal conduct
involving moral turpitude), 1-102(A)(4) (engaging in conduct involving
dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation), 1-102(A)(5) (engaging in conduct
that is prejudicial to the administration of justice), 1-102(A)(6) (engaging in any
other conduct that adversely reflects on the lawyer’s fitness to practice law), and
Gov.Bar R. V(4)(G) (duty to cooperate in an investigation of a complaint).
Respondent was served with the complaint on August 14, 1999. When he failed to
answer, relator filed a motion for default judgment.
        {¶ 2} A panel of the Board of Commissioners on Grievances and Discipline
of the Supreme Court (“board”) found that in October 1997, Alfred and Shirley
Paul advanced $50,000 to respondent in exchange for a thirty-day promissory note
with a fifteen-percent return. Respondent claimed to secure the note with shares of
                            SUPREME COURT OF OHIO




QuickStart Technologies, Inc., a California Corporation; however, respondent did
not have the authority to use whatever interest he had in that company as collateral
for the promissory note. The note was not paid when due and the Pauls expressed
concern to respondent, demanding payment. Respondent, however, made only one
payment of $10,000 to the Pauls.
       {¶ 3} The panel concluded that respondent’s actions violated DR 1-
102(A)(3), 1-102(A)(4), 1-102(A)(5), and 1-102(A)(6), and Gov.Bar R. V(4)(G).
The panel also noted that we previously disciplined respondent in Akron Bar Assn.
v. Bodnar (1999), 
84 Ohio St.3d 372
, 
704 N.E.2d 236
, for violation of DR 6-
101(A)(1) (a lawyer shall not handle a matter which he knows, or should know, he
is not competent to handle) and 6-101(A)(3) (a lawyer shall not neglect a legal
matter entrusted to him). In that case, we suspended respondent from the practice
of law for six months with the entire six-month suspension stayed. In light of this
prior violation and the absence of any mitigating circumstances, the panel
recommended permanent disbarment. The board adopted the findings, conclusions,
and recommendation of the panel.
                              __________________
       David Friedman and Stephen A. Fallis, for relator.
                              __________________
       Per Curiam.
       {¶ 4} We adopt the findings, conclusions, and recommendation of the
board. Respondent is hereby permanently disbarred from the practice of law in
Ohio. Costs are taxed to respondent.
                                                            Judgment accordingly.
       MOYER, C.J., DOUGLAS, RESNICK, F.E. SWEENEY and PFEIFER, JJ., concur.
       LUNDBERG STRATTON, J., dissents.
       COOK, J., not participating.
                              __________________




                                         2
                                January Term, 2000




       LUNDBERG STRATTON, J., dissenting.
       {¶ 5} I respectfully dissent. Respondent’s charges relate to the failure to
repay a loan he improperly collateralized. No one seems to dispute that respondent
did own stock in QuickStart Technologies, Inc. Therefore, there is no evidence that
he was deceitful regarding his ownership of the stock. Moreover, there appears to
be no allegation that he initially secured the loan intending not to repay it.
       {¶ 6} Defaults in personal matters are not usually cause for disbarment.
However, I believe that the combination of respondent’s misrepresentation of his
ability to pledge stock as collateral, his prior disciplinary matter, his behavior
subsequent to the default, and his failure to respond to this complaint warrant
further disciplinary action. But I do not believe that disbarment is the appropriate
sanction.
       {¶ 7} Therefore,     I   would    indefinitely   suspend    respondent    with
reinstatement conditioned upon full repayment of the loan.
                                __________________




                                         3

/2000/ohio/97 · .json · Public domain