Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2002 Ohio 4170

Cosby v. Cosby

Ohio Supreme Court

Decided August 28, 2002

Ohio Supreme Court · decided 2002-08-28

State Teachers Retirement System—Death of contributor—Beneficiaries—Court may not impose a constructive trust upon the State Teachers Retirement System survivor benefits of a surviving spouse in favor of a former spouse who claims entitlement based on an award of retirement benefits in a divorce decree.

Relies on Beatty v. . Guggenheim Exploration Co. · Ferguson v. Owens · Erb v. Erb

Decided 2002-08-28

[This decision has been published in Ohio Official Reports at 
96 Ohio St.3d 228
.]




                  COSBY, APPELLEE, v. COSBY, APPELLANT, ET AL.
                      [Cite as Cosby v. Cosby, 
2002-Ohio-4170
.]
State Teachers Retirement System—Death of contributor—Beneficiaries—Court
        may not impose a constructive trust upon the State Teachers Retirement
        System survivor benefits of a surviving spouse in favor of a former spouse
        who claims entitlement based on an award of retirement benefits in a
        divorce decree.
      (No. 2001-0659—Submitted April 9, 2002—Decided August 28, 2002.)
     APPEAL from the Court of Appeals for Butler County, No. CA99-11-192,
                                     
2001-Ohio-4205
.
                                  __________________
        LUNDBERG STRATTON, J.
        {¶1} The issue before us is whether a court may impose a constructive trust
upon the State Teachers Retirement System (“STRS”) survivor benefits of a
surviving spouse in favor of a former spouse who claims entitlement based on an
award of retirement benefits in a divorce decree. We find that a constructive trust
is an inappropriate remedy that is contrary to the statutory mandate of the STRS to
pay survivor benefits to a qualified surviving spouse when no retirement benefits
have vested. Consequently, we reverse the judgment of the court of appeals.
        {¶2} In 1989, appellee Faye Cosby and Carel Cosby divorced.                 The
judgment and divorce decree that terminated the marriage also provided for Faye
to receive a portion of Carel’s retirement fund upon his retirement:
        {¶3} “Upon the retirement of the plaintiff, the plaintiff will receive Sixty
(60%) Percent of his State Teacher’s Retirement Fund; and the defendant will
receive Forty (40%) Percent of said retirement fund. AND IT IS FURTHER
                            SUPREME COURT OF OHIO




ORDERED that the plaintiff will guarantee that the defendant receive at least One
Thousand ($1,000.00) Dollars per month from said retirement.”
       {¶4} Carel Cosby remarried and continued to work and contribute to STRS
until he died in 1997. Although he qualified for retirement, he did not apply for or
receive retirement benefits.    His surviving spouse, appellant Bonnie Cosby,
qualified as the statutory beneficiary of STRS survivor benefits payable under
former R.C. 3307.48 (144 Ohio Laws, Part IV, 6235) and 3307.49 (146 Ohio Laws,
Part I, 2026), now R.C. 3307.562 and 3307.66.
       {¶5} Appellee Faye Cosby filed this action, claiming that Bonnie Cosby had
been unjustly enriched by at least 40 percent of the STRS benefits she has received
and will receive in the future to the detriment of Faye Cosby. Faye Cosby asked
the trial court to impose a constructive trust on her behalf and to order Bonnie
Cosby to turn over 40 percent of the STRS benefits. She also named STRS as a
defendant and asked the court to require STRS to pay to her any funds remaining
in its possession that had not yet been paid to Bonnie Cosby.
       {¶6} The trial court dismissed STRS with prejudice, finding that the
complaint failed to state a claim against it upon which relief could be granted
because the STRS’s duty was statutory and it had no contractual obligation to Faye
Cosby. After a bench trial, the court held that the award in the divorce decree was
unambiguous and was triggered only by Carel Cosby’s retirement. Because he did
not retire, there was no basis for Faye Cosby to recover under the divorce decree.
The trial court dismissed with prejudice the complaint against Bonnie Cosby.
       {¶7} The court of appeals reversed and remanded to the trial court to enter
judgment in favor of plaintiff Faye Cosby. The appellate court reasoned that Faye
Cosby’s percentage of the retirement account was part of the division of marital
property and should be construed in accordance with the law governing division of
marital property and that the parties’ intent was not dispositive.       The court
concluded that Carel Cosby could not give to Bonnie Cosby property that the




                                         2
                               January Term, 2002




domestic relations court had previously awarded to his former spouse.
Consequently, the court deemed it unconscionable for Bonnie Cosby to retain the
entire benefit, and ruled that Bonnie had been unjustly enriched and that equity
supported the creation of a constructive trust in favor of Faye Cosby.
       {¶8} The dissenting judge, referring to the benefits at issue as “death”
benefits, stated that they are not the equivalent of retirement benefits under STRS.
He reasoned that a constructive trust was inappropriate because Carel Cosby’s
pension benefits never vested, citing R.C. 3307.42. Bonnie Cosby was the statutory
beneficiary who was entitled to receive the STRS benefits under R.C. 3307.562, he
concluded.
       {¶9} This cause is before this court on allowance of a discretionary appeal.
       {¶10} We begin by examining the STRS. The STRS is the statutorily
created public retirement system for public school teachers in Ohio, and as a
government retirement system, it is exempt from federal ERISA requirements.
Section 1003(b)(1), Title 29, U.S.Code; R.C. Chapter 3307. STRS membership is
composed of teachers who are employed in a public school system. The system is
funded by its members, who must contribute a portion of their salaries to the
system. R.C. 3307.26 (formerly 3307.51, 144 Ohio Laws, Part II, 2089). The
STRS is administered and implemented according to statute.
       {¶11} STRS pays various statutorily mandated benefits to retired members,
their surviving spouses, and other qualified dependents. R.C. 3307.58 (formerly
3307.38) requires STRS to pay a pension to members who qualify and then apply
for retirement benefits. 
Id.
 The benefits do not vest until STRS grants the
retirement. R.C. 3307.42 (formerly 3307.711, 126 Ohio Laws 1077); see, also,
State ex rel. Horvath v. State Teachers Retirement Bd. (1998), 
83 Ohio St.3d 67
,
697 N.E.2d 644
.
       {¶12} If a member dies before retiring, no retirement benefits will vest and
no contractual right to retirement benefits will arise. R.C. 3307.42; see Horvath.




                                         3
                               SUPREME COURT OF OHIO




However, the right to a survivor benefit arises in the deceased member’s designated
beneficiary. R.C. 3307.562 and 3307.66 (formerly 3307.48 and 3307.49). If the
member has not expressly designated a beneficiary, then the surviving spouse at the
time of the member’s death is the first person who is statutorily entitled to the
survivor benefit. R.C. 3307.562(C)(1). A member’s divorce automatically revokes
the designation of a former spouse as a beneficiary. R.C. 3307.562(B).
        {¶13} The court below referred to the STRS survivor benefits at issue as a
death benefit. This is incorrect. Payment of a death benefit is made after a member
dies while receiving STRS retirement benefits. R.C. 3307.661 (formerly 3307.40,
144 Ohio Laws, Part II, 2077) and 3307.392. When that occurs, STRS will pay a
death benefit consisting of a one-time lump-sum payment to a qualified beneficiary.
Id.
        {¶14} Faye Cosby bases her claim upon the divorce decree, which awarded
her a percentage of her former husband’s STRS retirement fund “[u]pon the
retirement” of her husband. There was evidence before the trial court that attorneys
for the parties in the divorce action did not contemplate Carel Cosby’s death prior
to retirement. Therefore, Faye contends that the intent was to provide her with a
portion of the retirement funds whether Carel retired or died prior to retirement.
She acknowledges the statutory distinction between retirement and survivor
benefits; however, she claims that the distinction is irrelevant for purposes of the
intent of the parties in the divorce to vest in her a portion of the STRS account.
        {¶15} Bonnie Cosby contends that STRS retirement benefits are separate
and distinct from the STRS survivor benefits that she is receiving. This position
was further emphasized by the Attorney General, who filed a brief on behalf of
amicus curiae STRS, as well as four other public retirement systems. 1 According


1. The amici curiae include the Public Employees Retirement System of Ohio, the School
Employees Retirement System of Ohio, the Ohio State Highway Patrol Retirement System, and the
Ohio Police and Fire Pension Fund.




                                             4
                                January Term, 2002




to amici, Ohio’s public retirement systems, including STRS, can pay benefits only
as expressly authorized by statute. Erb v. Erb (1996), 
75 Ohio St.3d 18, 22
, 
661 N.E.2d 175
. Because Carel Cosby died prior to retirement, his retirement benefits
did not vest. STRS is statutorily prohibited from paying retirement benefits until a
member has actually retired. 
Id.
       {¶16} However, STRS was obligated to pay survivor benefits to Carel
Cosby’s surviving spouse under R.C. 3307.562.            Even if Carel Cosby had
designated Faye Cosby as beneficiary for those benefits, that designation would
have been automatically revoked as a result of the divorce. R.C. 3307.562(B).
Consequently, Bonnie Cosby became entitled to her husband’s survivor benefits
pursuant to R.C. 3307.562(C)(1) as his surviving spouse. According to amici, she
is the only lawful beneficiary to these benefits under Ohio law.
       {¶17} The appellate court’s analysis blurred the statutory distinction
between retirement and survivor benefits. Instead of the statutory requirements, the
court focused on what it believed was the intent of the parties in the divorce action
to provide for Faye Cosby from her ex-spouse’s STRS fund. The appellate court
fashioned an equitable remedy in the form of a constructive trust to reach the STRS
funds in order to afford Faye relief. A constructive trust is an equitable remedy that
may be used “ ‘[w]hen property has been acquired in such circumstances that the
holder of the legal title may not in good conscience retain the beneficial interest.’ ”
Ferguson v. Owens (1984), 
9 Ohio St.3d 223, 225
, 9 OBR 565, 
459 N.E.2d 1293
,
quoting Beatty v. Guggenheim Exploration Co. (1919), 
225 N.Y. 380, 386
, 
122 N.E. 378
.
       {¶18} However, the appellate court failed to examine the statutory nature
of the STRS benefits. In the divorce decree, Faye Cosby was awarded a portion of
her former spouse’s retirement benefits. Those benefits never vested. Instead,
upon the death of Carel Cosby, STRS was required to pay survivor benefits to
Bonnie Cosby.




                                          5
                               SUPREME COURT OF OHIO




         {¶19} STRS benefits are governed exclusively by statute. Bonnie Cosby,
as the qualified statutory beneficiary of Carel Cosby’s STRS account, is currently
receiving or has received survivor benefits under R.C. 3307.562. The court of
appeals’ decision imposing a constructive trust over a portion of Bonnie Cosby’s
benefits for the benefit of Faye Cosby is contrary to the statutory mandates of
STRS. While we sympathize with Faye Cosby’s situation, we are bound by the
statutory mandates of the STRS and cannot ignore their requirements. Although
we may not like the result, a different solution lies only with the General Assembly.
Consequently, we reverse the judgment of the court of appeals and reinstate the
judgment of the trial court.
                                                                    Judgment reversed.
         MOYER, C.J., and F.E. SWEENEY, J., concur.
         COOK, J., concurs in judgment.
         DOUGLAS, J., dissents.
         RESNICK and PFEIFER, JJ., dissent.
                                  __________________
         ALICE ROBIE RESNICK, J., dissenting.
         {¶20} The majority expresses sympathy for Faye Cosby’s plight but
nevertheless asserts that it is limited by the statutory mandates of the State Teachers
Retirement System (“STRS”) and therefore overturns the judgment of the court of
appeals that a constructive trust be imposed.          This case does not present a
straightforward exercise in statutory construction but must be considered in light of
its specific facts. The constructive-trust doctrine, with its origins in equity, is
especially well suited to provide relief in just such a situation as is presented in this
case.    Finding that the court of appeals was correct in determining that a
constructive trust is appropriate on these facts, I would affirm the judgment of that
court.




                                           6
                                January Term, 2002




       {¶21} The relevant provision in the divorce decree terminating the marriage
of Faye Cosby and Carel Cosby states, “Upon the retirement of the plaintiff [Carel
Cosby], the plaintiff will receive Sixty (60%) Percent of his State Teacher’s
Retirement Fund; and the defendant will receive Forty (40%) Percent of said
retirement fund.    AND IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the plaintiff will
guarantee that the defendant receive at least One Thousand ($1,000.00) Dollars per
month from said retirement.” (Emphasis added.)
       {¶22} An examination of this provision reveals that the parties in the
divorce were splitting Carel Cosby’s “retirement fund” or retirement account.
References to the “retirement fund” show that that term was used in a generic way
to specify that whatever STRS benefits were to go to Carel Cosby would be split
60-40 at the time those benefits were received. It is evident that any STRS benefits,
no matter how characterized, were within the contemplations of the parties in
providing for this division.
       {¶23} “Retirement” in the sense in which it was used is not the strict
technical statutory definition contained in the STRS statutes but is a general term
meant to encompass any STRS benefits, including the survivor benefits that are at
issue. Therefore, it is not dispositive that Carel Cosby’s retirement benefits never
vested pursuant to R.C. 3307.42. The majority focuses on the statutory terms
entirely too much and misses this essential point.
       {¶24} Contrary to appellant Bonnie Cosby’s arguments, a constructive trust
can be imposed even when there is no indication of wrongdoing by anyone. This
court has recognized that although a constructive trust is most often imposed as a
remedy for fraudulent conduct, “a constructive trust may also be imposed where it
is against the principles of equity that the property be retained by a certain person
even though the property was acquired without fraud.” Ferguson v. Owens (1984),
9 Ohio St.3d 223, 226
, 9 OBR 565, 
459 N.E.2d 1293
.




                                         7
                             SUPREME COURT OF OHIO




       {¶25} The brief filed by the Attorney General on behalf of amicus curiae
STRS and the other state retirement systems reveals that Carel Cosby had not
designated a beneficiary for his survivor benefits, so that Bonnie Cosby
automatically became the recipient of those benefits as his surviving spouse
pursuant to R.C. 3307.562(C)(1). However, if Carel Cosby had designated a
beneficiary in accordance with R.C. 3307.562(B) (former R.C. 3307.48, 144 Ohio
Laws, Part IV, 6235), it appears that he could have specifically provided that Faye
Cosby would receive 40 percent of his survivor benefits. Furthermore, if Faye
Cosby had been designated as a 40-percent beneficiary after Carel Cosby married
Bonnie Cosby, the automatic revocation provision regarding a former spouse
contained within R.C. 3307.562(B) would have been overridden. Of course, Carel
Cosby did not take this action.       Imposition of a constructive trust in these
circumstances is necessary to carry out the mutually expressed intention of Carel
Cosby and Faye Cosby as incorporated in their 1989 divorce decree.
       {¶26} The equities favor the imposition of a constructive trust. Faye Cosby
and Carel Cosby were married for 37 years. As the court of appeals recognized,
the STRS benefits of Carel Cosby were accumulated as a product of the joint efforts
of Carel Cosby and Faye Cosby during their marriage.          When the marriage
concluded, these interests were included within the property settlement. Carel
Cosby gave up something (and Faye Cosby received something) in the divorce, but
according to the majority, as it turns out in the end, Faye Cosby receives nothing
and Bonnie Cosby gets it all, despite the obligations that Carel Cosby undertook in
the divorce decree.
       {¶27} The court of appeals believed that it is unconscionable for Bonnie
Cosby to retain all of Carel Cosby’s STRS benefits, and that Bonnie Cosby is
unjustly enriched by her retention of the entire amount. Because I fully agree with
the essential reasoning of the court of appeals, I dissent.
       PFEIFER, J., concurs in the foregoing dissenting opinion.




                                           8
                                January Term, 2002




                              __________________
       Fred Miller, for appellee.
       John M. Holcomb, for appellant.
       Betty D. Montgomery, Attorney General, and Christopher S. Cook,
Assistant Attorney General, for amici curiae State Teachers Retirement System, the
Public Employees Retirement System of Ohio, the School Employees Retirement
System of Ohio, the Ohio State Highway Patrol Retirement System, and the Ohio
Police and Fire Pension Fund.
                              __________________




                                         9

/2002/ohio/4170 · .json · Public domain