Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2014 Pa. Super. 220

101 A.3d 801

Commonwealth v. Valentine

Superior Court of Pennsylvania

Decided October 3, 2014

Superior Court of Pennsylvania · decided 2014-10-03

Cited by 26 later decisions — most recently February 2023 · most notably Commonwealth, Aplt. v. Hopkins, K. (2015), Commonwealth v. Washington, T., Aplt. (2016)

1 federal appellate · 21 state decisions

Relies on Alleyne v. United States · 2014 Pa. Super. 178 - Commonwealth v. Newman · 2014 Pa. Super. 102 - Commonwealth v. Buterbaugh

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 2014-10-03

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1*813CONCURRING OPINION BY

GANTMAN, P.J.:

¶2I agree with the majority that sufficient evidence supported Appellant’s robbery conviction. I am also compelled to agree that we must vacate the judgment of sentence and remand for re-sentencing, given the binding nature of this Court’s recent en banc decision in Commonwealth v. Newman, 99 A.3d 86 (2014). The majority logically extends Newmanto declare that 42 Pa.C.S.A. §§ 9712 and 9713 are likewise unconstitutional.

¶3I write separately, however, to address an alternative available to the court upon re-sentencing. The sentencing court, perhaps, could apply a deadly weapon enhancement to Appellant’s sentence without running afoul of Newman. See Commonwealth v. Buterbaugh, 91 A.3d 1247, 1270 n. 10 (Pa.Super.2014) (explaining that if sentencing enhancement applies, court is required to raise standard guideline range; however, court retains discretion to sentence outside guideline range; therefore, application of sentencing enhancement does not violate holding in Alleyne v. United States, — U.S. -, 133 S.Ct. 2151, 186 L.Ed.2d 314 (2013)).

¶4Thus, I accept the majority’s ultimate decision to vacate the judgment of sentence and remand for re-sentencing without consideration of mandatory mínimums set forth in Sections 9712 and 9713. Accordingly, I concur in the result.

¶5Judge ALLEN joins this Concurring Opinion.

¶6Justice FITZGERALD joins this Concurring Opinion.

/2014/pasuper/220 · .json · Public domain