Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2016 DNH 3

Posteraro v Citizens Financial

New Hampshire District Court

Decided January 5, 2016

New Hampshire District Court · decided 2016-01-05

Relies on 611 F. Supp. 2d 78 - Aumand v. Dartmouth Hitchcock Medical Center · Westerdahl v. Williams

Decided 2016-01-05

                     UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                       DISTRICT OF NEW HAMPSHIRE


Jennifer Posteraro

     v.                              Civil No. 13-cv-416-JL
                                     Opinion No. 
2016 DNH 003P
Citizens Financial Group




                      ORDER ON MOTIONS IN LIMINE

     Before the court are the parties’ respective motions in

limine seeking to exclude various evidentiary items and issues

from the upcoming trial in the above-captioned matter.    Plaintiff

Jennifer Posteraro sued her former employer, Citizens Financial

Group (“Citizens”), and her former manager, Christos Hatzidakis,

for, inter alia, violations of state and federal gender and

disability discrimination laws.    The court recently granted the

bulk of defendants' motion for summary judgment (doc. no. 63).

Accordingly, the only claims remaining for trial are Counts 5 and

6 against Citizens, which allege retaliation for complaining

about sexual harassment and pursuing accommodation for her

disabilities, in violation of Title VII and 
N.H. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 354
-A:19.

     Each side has filed motions in limine seeking to exclude

evidence from   trial.   The court preliminarily addressed these

motions at the final pre-trial conference held on December 30,
2015.1     As promised, the court makes the following, more detailed

findings on the pending motions.        The court reminds the parties

that all of the rulings herein are made without prejudice to

revisiting particular issues in response to circumstances that

might arise during trial.      Furthermore, these ruling are limited

to grounds argued in the parties' filings.       The court reserves

the right to assess other factors at trial, such as authenticity,

hearsay and best evidence.      See Fed. R. Evid. 800 et seq., 900

et. seq., and 1000 et seq.


I.   Citizens' Motions

A.   Motion to exclude expert testimony (doc. no. 43)

          Posteraro based her disability-related claims on diagnoses

of post-traumatic stress disorder (“PTSD”), anxiety and

depression.      Citizens seeks to exclude expert testimony regarding

PTSD and her treatment for anxiety and depression.       The

ostensible bases for the motion is Posteraro’s failure to

properly disclose experts on those matters.

     The court first observes that by granting summary judgment

on Posteraro’s substantive ADA claim, the court has rendered much

of the testimony on the issue of her disabilities irrelevant.

Fed. R. Evid. 401.      While such testimony might be relevant to the


      1
      Counsel declined the opportunity for oral argument at the
pre-trial conference.

                                    2
limited issue of whether Citizens’ alleged retaliation caused or

exacerbated any of Posteraro’s medical conditions, Posteraro has

made no disclosure of any non-retained experts on this subject,

as is required by Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(a)(2)(A), (c) and (D).    As

the court noted in Aumand v. Dartmouth Hitchcock Med. Ctr., 
611 F. Supp. 2d 78, 88
 (D.N.H. 2009), the failure to disclose still

allows Posteraro’s treatment providers to testify about “‘what

they saw and what they did’ in the course of caring for a

patient; that would be fact testimony, rather than opinion

testimony under Rule 702.   But going beyond those facts triggers

the disclosure requirement . . . .”   To be sure, a treating

physician can testify, absent a report, as to causation,

diagnosis, prognosis and extent of disability “provided that [he

or she] reached that conclusion in a reliable manner while

examining and treating the plaintiff.”   Westerdahl v. Williams,

276 F.R.D. 405, 408
 (D.N.H. 2011) (citation and internal

quotation omitted).   But here, Posteraro’s objection to the

instant motion does not cite any diagnoses or opinions that her

treating physicians reached during the course of treatment.2

Accordingly, Citizens’ motion to exclude expert testimony (doc.

no. 43) is granted to the extent it seeks to preclude Posteraro’s


     2
      For example, Citizens points out that references to PTSD in
the medical records were based on Posteraro’s own reports to her
providers, rather than through clinical assessments by them.

                                 3
treating physicians from offering opinion testimony not based on

their treatment.


B.   Motion to exclude evidence of lost wages or benefits
     (Doc No. 44)

     Posteraro originally sought lost wages based on her claims

of wrongful termination and constructive discharge.   However, the

court granted summary judgment as to those claims, rendering

evidence regarding lost wages or benefits irrelevant.      Fed. R.

Evid. 401, 402.    Moreover, Posteraro has provided no authority

for the proposition (and has not seriously or articulately

argued) that she is entitled to recover lost wages for the

periods of her leave that she requested as an accommodation under

the ADA.   Accordingly, Citizens’motion to exclude evidence of

lost wages or benefits (doc. no. 44) is granted.


C.   Motion to exclude evidence of damages after January 20,
     2014, based on after-acquired evidence of misconduct (Doc.
     No. 45)

     Citizens notes that in January 2014, during the course of

discovery, it learned that Posteraro had been involuntarily

terminated by two previous employers, facts which she did not

disclose in her Citizens employment application.   Citizens claims

that had it still employed Posteraro, it would have terminated

her upon learning this information.   Therefore, any accumulation

of damages should end at that date.   The court need not

                                  4
specifically reach the issue, however, as the grant of summary

judgment in Citizens’ favor on Posteraro’s wrongful termination

and constructive discharge claims renders any lost wage evidence

irrelevant.    Fed. R. Evid. 401, 402.   Accordingly, Citizens'

motion to exclude evidence of damages after January 20, 2014

(doc. no. 45), is granted.3


D.   Motion to exclude evidence derived from Christos
     Hatzidakis's personnel file (Doc. No. 46)

     Citizens argues that evidence of branch manager Hatzidakis’s

poor performance or of disciplinary action it took against him

for performance-related issues is irrelevant.    The court

disagrees.    The only claim remaining in this case is for

retaliation.    As the court observed in its summary judgment

order, there was evidence from which a jury could find that

Hatzidakis retaliated against Posteraro because her protected

activity – harassment complaints – “[got] him in trouble” with

his superiors.    
2015 DNH 237
, 29.   Accordingly, to the extent

that evidence in Hatzidakis’s personnel file is relevant to



     3
       Citizens also claims in its objection to plaintiff’s
exhibits (doc. no. 55 at 3 n.1) that Posteraro conceded in an
interrogatory answer that medical symptoms attributable to her
employment at Citizens ended about a year after her departure,
i.e., August 2012. As plaintiff’s interrogatory answers are not
(yet) part of the record, the court does not pass on this
assertion. If accurate, however, it would be a substantial
impediment to a damage claim beyond that date.

                                  5
Posteraro’s retaliation claim – perhaps as corroboration of her

claims of retaliatory conduct or to establish a motive to

retaliate –   Citizens’ motion to exclude evidence derived from

Christos Hatzidakis's personnel file (doc. no. 46) is denied.4


E.    Motion to exclude evidence regarding Genisa Todisco
     (Doc. No. 47)

     In her objection to Citizens’ motion for summary judgment,

Posteraro made reference to alleged discrimination against

Todisco, a former Citizens employee, as well as a discrimination

case filed by Todisco against Citizens, which now seeks to

exclude such evidence from trial.    To the extent Posteraro

intended to proffer this evidence to support a hostile

environment claim, she may not do so, as the court granted

summary judgment as this claim, rendering the evidence irrelevant

for that purpose.   Fed. R. Evid. 401, 402.   While Todisco’s

treatment conceivably might be admissible as a “crime, wrong, or

other act” under Fed. R. Evid. 404(b)(2), Posteraro has made no

such argument.   Therefore, Citizens’ motion to exclude evidence

regarding Genisa Todisco (doc. no. 47) is granted.



      4
       The court’s task is complicated by plaintiff’s failure to
separately identify the particular documents from Hatzidakis’s
personnel file she intends to offer at trial, as required by L.R.
16.2(a)(5). Regardless, the court declines to categorically
exclude disciplinary or performance-related information from the
file.

                                 6
II.    Posteraro's motion

A.    Motion to preclude evidence of other litigation (Doc. No. 49)

      Posteraro seeks to exclude evidence of her involvement in

litigation against two other employers:    one that preceded

Citizens and one that followed.    Citizens argues that evidence

from those actions might help demonstrate that the complained-of

conduct at Citizens was not unwelcome or that she was not

actually intimidated by Hatzidakis’s alleged conduct.    Given the

grant of summary judgment in Citizens’ favor on Posteraro’s

harassment claims, such evidence is not relevant. Fed. R. Evid.

401, 402.    Moreover, whatever probative value can be assigned to

the mere fact that Posteraro has been in legal skirmishes with

other employers, such value is outweighed by the potential

prejudice of her being seen as unreasonably or unjustifiably

litigious.    Fed. R. Evid. 403.   Therefore, Posteraro's motion to

exclude evidence of other litigation (doc. no. 49) is granted.

However, this ruling does not necessarily preclude the

introduction of particular evidence from such other litigation

for permissible purposes, such as credibility, damages, or

causation.




                                   7
III.       Conclusion

       As set forth herein, and subject to the caveats noted,

Citizens’ motion to exclude expert testimony5 is GRANTED;

Citizens’ motion to exclude evidence of lost wages or benefits6

is GRANTED; Citizens’ motion to exclude evidence of damages after

January 20, 20147 is GRANTED; Citizens’ motion to exclude

evidence derived from Christos Hatzidakis’s personnel file8 is

DENIED; Citizens’ motion to exclude evidence regarding Genisa

Todisco9 is GRANTED; Posteraro’s motion to exclude evidence of

other litigation10 is GRANTED.


       SO ORDERED.



                                 Joseph N. Laplante
                                 United States District Judge

Dated: January 5, 2016

cc:    John P. Sherman, Esq.
       K. Joshua Scott, Esq.
       Martha Van Oot, Esq.
       Debra Weiss Ford, Esq.

       5
           Doc. no. 43.
       6
           Doc. no. 44.
       7
           Doc. no. 45.
       8
           Doc. no. 46.
       9
           Doc. no. 47.
       10
            Doc. no. 49.

                                   8

/2016/dnh/3 · .json · Public domain