Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

207 Misc. 845

People v. Cooper

New York County Courts

Decided May 27, 1955

New York County Courts · decided 1955-05-27

Cited by 6 later decisions — most recently January 1988

6 state decisions

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“"Any person who carnally abuses the body of a child of over the age of ten years and less than sixteen years of age, or who indulges in any indecent or immoral practice with the sexual parts or organs of any such child, in a manner other than by an act of sexual intercourse, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor." ..... The language of Section 483-a clearly encompasses two categories. First, a child of the age of ten years, and second, a child under ten years. Section 483-b includes but one category, a child of over the age of ten years, and less than sixteen. Words in penal statutes are to be given their commonly accepted meaning. A child becomes ten years old upon reaching his tenth birthday and remains a child of the age of ten until he reaches his eleventh birthday. The language of Section 483-a makes this abundantly clear. Had the legislature intended to exclude from this section any child who has reached his tenth birthday the language used would have been "less than ten years of age," just as Section 483-b uses the words "less than sixteen years of age." Reading the two sections together makes it clear that a child of ten years, that is, one who has not reached his eleventh birthday is included in the language of Section 483-a, and that a child over the age of ten years, that is, one who has become eleven, is included in the language of 483-b. People v. Cooper, 207 Misc. 845 , 143 N.Y.S.2d 855 (Tompkins County Court 1955)”

quoted by 1 later decision, including State v. Carroll

“"Any person of the age of eighteen years or over who carnally abuses the body, or indulges in any indecent or immoral practices with the sexual parts or organs of a child of the age of ten years or under, shall be guilty of a felony."”

quoted by 1 later decision, including State v. Carroll

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1955-05-27

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Stagg, J.

¶1The defendant hap been indicted by the Grand Jury for the crime of carnal abuse of a child in that said defendant 1 ‘ indulged in indecent and immoral practices with the sexual part and organs of an infant of the age of 10 years. ’ ’

¶2The defendant has demurred to the indictment oL the ground that he cannot tell whether the crime alleged is for violation of section 483-a or 483-b of the Penal Law.

¶3Section 483-a reads in part as follows: ‘ ‘ Any person of the age of eighteen years or over who carnally abuses the body, or indulges in any indecent or immoral practices with the sexual parts or organs of a child of the age of ten years or under, shall be guilty of a felony ’ ’.

¶4Section 483-b reads in part as follows: ‘ ‘ Any person who carnally abuses the body of a child of over the age of ten years and less than sixteen years of age, or who indulges in any indecent or immoral practice with the sexual parts or organs of *846any such child, in a manner other than by an act of sexual intercourse, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor ”.

¶5Prior to the amendment of 1950 (L. 1950, ch. 292), the pertinent portion of section 483-b read as follows: “ Any person who carnally abuses the body of a child of the age of ten years and over and less than sixteen years of age ”.

¶6This language did present a conflict, since both sections included a child of ten years of age. The amendment, however, eliminated this overlap, and the legislative intent is now clear.

¶7The language of section 483-a clearly encompasses two categories. First, a child of the age of ten years, and second, a child under ten years. Section 483-b includes but one category, a child of over the age of ten years, and less than sixteen.

¶8Words in penal statutes are to be given their commonly accepted meaning. A child becomes ten years old upon reaching his tenth birthday and remains a child of the age of ten until he reaches his eleventh birthday. The language of section 483-a makes this abundantly clear. Had the Legislature intended to exclude from this section any child who has reached his tenth birthday the language used would have been 11 less than ten years of age ”, just as section 483-b uses the words less than sixteen years of age ’ ’.

¶9Reading the two sections together makes it clear that a child of ten years, that is, one who has not reached his eleventh birthday is included in the language of section 483-a, and that a child over the age of ten years, that is, one who has become eleven, is included in the language of 483-b.

¶10The demurrer is overruled.

/207/misc/845 · .json · Public domain