Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

21 Ala. App. 113

105 So 430

Spates v. Campbell

Alabama Court of Appeals

Decided August 11, 1925

Alabama Court of Appeals · decided 1925-08-11

Decided 1925-08-11

BRICKEN, P. J.

¶1 Appellee, Campbell, brought an action of detinue against appellant Spates, for the recovery of one brown mare mule, 8 years old.

¶2 The case was tried by the court without a jury. Errors are assigned all relating, however, to the same proposition, “that the court erred in its finding and judgment in favor of the plaintiff.”

¶3 The bill of exceptions states that “this was all the testimony in substance,” however, there is no evidence whatever incorporated in the bill of exceptions as to the value of the mule involved. We must presume that there was other evidence, otherwise the court could not have arrived at the value of the mule.

¶4 The evidence was in direct conflict, and *114 in.this state of the record we cannot disturb the finding and judgment of the trial court. The judgment will stand affirmed.

¶5 Affirmed.

/21/alaapp/113 · .json · Public domain