Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

21 Iowa 538

Greenheld v. Morrison

Supreme Court of Iowa

Decided December 21, 1866

Supreme Court of Iowa · decided 1866-12-21

This action originated in the County Court of Lee county. The plaintiff filed in said court his petition, claiming one-lialf of the personal estate, amounting to thirteen hundred dollars (after the payment of the debts and expenses of administration), of Robert Stanforth, deceased, of which estate the defendant, Morrison, is executor.

' To this petition the defendant demurred, because the… · Decided 1866-12-21

Cole, J.

¶1. 1. Aliens : pSsoXai* property. The only question made by the demurrer is, as to the right and capacity of a non-resident alien to take a distributive share of an intestate’s estate in this State. question need arise in the determination of this case, as to the construction of the act of 1858 (Rev., § 2188 to 2193), since, so far as that act relates to personal property, it is probably only declarative of the common law.

¶2At the common law, aliens are capable of acquiring, holding and transmitting movable property, in like manner as our own citizens, and they can bring suits for the i-ecovery of that property. 2 Kent’s Com., 62. Aliens are not deprived of any of these rights by our statutes. The provision of our statute (Rev., § 2122), which provides that personal property “shall be distributed to the same persons and in the same proportion as though it were real estate,” does not prevent aliens *540from taking distributive shares of personal estate, although non-resident aliens might not take real estate'by descent.

¶3Our statute provides (Rev., § 2436), that the real estate of a decedent, subject to dower, &c., “ shall descend in equal shares to his children.” Yet if any of his children are non-resident aliens (aside from some other statute on the subject), such non-resident alien children would not take any portion, for that he would have no inheritable blood. In other words, both these sections, like all other statutes, are construed, in the light of and with reference to the common law relating to the same subject-matter.

¶4Affirmed.

/21/iowa/538 · .json · Public domain