Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

21 La. Ann. 727

Samuel v. Winkelman

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided November 15, 1869

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1869-11-15

<p>Whoro a lease lias boen given for one year, with a privilege of renewal for five years, and a third party binds himself as surety for the lease, and the lease is renewed at the expiration of *the year, the surety is not bound on tho extended lease, unless it is shown that he consented to the extension.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1869-11-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 8 later decisions — most recently January 1990

7 state decisions

2018691870188018901900191019201930194019501960197019801990decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Howell, J.

¶1-Tho, plaintiffs leased to tho defendant lYinkelman certain property for one year, from first August, 1865, with tho privilege of renewing the lease for-four years more for the same price and under the same conditions, provided written notice he given to the lessors at least throe months before the thirty-first July, I860. The defendant Frank Ileuer intervened in the act, and “ declared that he hereby hinds himself, jointly and in solido, with and as security for tho said lessee, for the punctual payment of the rent heroin stipulated, and of all costs and damages resulting from -any violation of any of the conditions of tho foregoing lease, hereby consenting to he hound as if ho were tho principal obligor herein, and renouncing tho plea and benefit of discussion or division granted by law to sureties.”

¶2The thirty days’ notice was given by the lessee; and in September, *7281867, this suit was instituted for the quarterly rent due on first of August of that yoar. The defendants filed separate answers, Heuer alleging that his responsibility ceased on thirty-first July, 1366, and was not renewed. Judgment was rendered against both in solido, and Heuer appealed.

¶3There is no proof that Heuer consented to the extension or renewal of the lease; but plaintiffs say that by his contract he was as much their tenant as Winkelman, and that the acts of the latter were his acts, of which ho is not permitted to plead ignorance. This position is untenable. The lease was niado to Winkelman as the tenant, and Heuer became his security, bound, it is true, as if he were the principal obligor in the lease, but only for the term of that lease, to wit, one year. The faculty of renewing was a privilege or right, to bo exercised by the lessee upon a given condition, and not an obligation assumed by the surety. lie was liable to the same obligations as the debtor himself (C. C. 8014, 2036) during the lease, but ho did not agree to be bound in the renewed or extended lease by the giving of the required notice to the lessors by the lessee. The clause in relation to the renewal oidy bound the lessors and the lessee to the same price and conditions, if the lease were renewed, as contemplated. The consent of the surety was necessary to bind him on the extended lease. His consent cannot be presumed from the terms of the original lease.

¶4It is, therefore, ordered, that the judgment herein against Frank Heuer be reversed, and that there bo judgment in his-.favor, with his costs in both courts.

¶5Rehearing refused.

/21/laann/727 · .json · Public domain