Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

21 Miss. 551

Person v. Valentine

Mississippi Supreme Court

Decided January 15, 1850

Mississippi Supreme Court · decided 1850-01-15

In error from the circuit court of Claiborne county; Hon. Stanhope Posey, judge. On the 22d of May, 1843, the bank of Port Gibson recovered judgment in the Claiborne circuit court, against Richard Valentine and John Patterson, for $362. At the May term, 1845, judgment of forfeiture was rendered against said bank, and James J. Person and James T. Marye, were duly appointed trustees thereof.

Decided 1850-01-15

Mr; Justice Clayton

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2This was a scire facias issued to revive a judgment obtained by the Bank of Port Gibson against the defendants in error. They pleaded to the scire facias that a judgment of forfeiture had been rendered against the bank, and that prior to the rendition of the judgment in this case, the bank had assigned the note sued on to. certain persons as its assignees. A replication was filed- to this plea, to which a demurrer was filed, and which is claimed to be extended to-the plea.

¶3This case differs from Person & Marye v. Daniel Yates, decided at the present term of the court, and those of similar character previously decided, in this, that in those cases, the plea was tendered to the original action, before the rendition of the judgment.; in this it is offered to the scire facias issued to revive *553the judgment. It is a settled rule that the defendant cannot plead any matter to a scire facias on a judgment, which he might have pleaded to the original action, or which existed prior to the judgment. The rule is the same, whether the judgment was obtained by confession, or default, or upon plea. 1 Robertson, Prac. 585. McFarland v. Irwin, 8 Johns. Rep. 78.

¶4The application of this principle excludes the plea in this case, and makes the judgment of the court below erroneous.

¶5It is therefore reversed, the said plea adjudged to be insufficient, and the cause remanded for further proceedings.

¶6Judgment reversed.

/21/miss/551 · .json · Public domain