Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

21 ND 211

Erickson v. Russ

North Dakota Supreme Court

Decided January 25, 1911

North Dakota Supreme Court · decided 1911-01-25

Action by Peter C. Erickson against _Peter P. Russ and another to foreclose a mechanics’ lien. Prom a judgment sustaining the demurrer of defendant Mary L. Russ to the complaint, plaintiff appeals.

Reversed with directions to overrule demurrer · Decided 1911-01-25

Burke, J.

¶1This is a companion case to Erickson v. Russ, ante, 208, decided to-day by this court. An examination of the opinion in said case will disclose the facts in this case and also dispose of most of the questions of law arising on this record.

¶2The defendant Mary L. Russ, this respondent, however, makes the further point that, “before the property of a third party can be subject to the payment of the debt of another, the complaint must allege that an execution has been issued against the property of the -principal debtor,, and returned unsatisfied.”

¶3Even if this statement were true,’ it would not apply to the case at bar. The plaintiff herein is not seeking to enforce his debt against Mary L. Russ, nor to hold her as guarantor. He does not ask for a de*212ficiency judgment against her. He is in pursuit of property upon which he has a valid lien, and asks only that his lien be adjudged to be prior to the claim of respondent; that said property be sold to satisfy his said lien, and, if necessary, for a deficiency judgment against Peter P. Russ alone.

¶4The demurrer should have been overruled, and the District Court will so order.

All concur.
/21/nd/211 · .json · Public domain