Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

21 N.H. 232

Toppan v. Jenness

Superior Court of New Hampshire

Decided July 15, 1850

Superior Court of New Hampshire · decided 1850-07-15

Assumpsit, for goods sold,and delivered. The defendant, with the general issue, gave a notice of set-off. There was no controversy as to the plaintiff’s claim. Held: that upon the general issue the plaintiff is always entitled to the closing argument. Exceptions were taken to the rulings and instructions of the court, by the defendant’s counsel, who moved that the verdict returned for the plaintiff might be set aside.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1850-07-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently June 1879

4 state decisions

20185018601870decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Bell, J.

¶1The Revised Statutes, ch. 187, § 10, p. 376, seem to us entirely decisive as to the question whether the defendant could avail himself of the order of Dennet and the plaintiff’s acceptance, as a set-off. “ No debt or demand shall be set off as aforesaid unless a right of action existed thereon at the commencement of the plaintiff’s action.” The right of action upon the acceptance, depended entirely upon the fact whether the condition, upon which the acceptor had agreed to pay, was performed or not; and as no right of action could exist till then, if; could not be set off by the terms of the statute.

¶2*234The case of The Pemigiwasset Bank v. Brackett, 4 N. H. Rep. 557, is conclusive as tb the effect of the payment after action brought, that it cannot go in bar of the action, unless specially pleaded puis darrein continuance, in bar of the further maintenance of the action.

¶3It has always, so far as we are aware, been tbe practice for tbe plaintiff’s counsel to open and close tbe case when tbe general issue is pleaded, whatever may be tbe nature of tbe controversy. Ayer v. Austin, 6 Pick. 225.

¶4Judgment on the Verdict.

/21/nh/232 · .json · Public domain