21 R.I. 48 - In Re Holder

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently July 1974

5 state decisions

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

Matteson, C. J.

¶1 The testatrix directs her executor, as soon as practicable after her death, to sell the real estate known as the Steere Homestead, and after payment of the expenses of sale to distribute the remaining proceeds as follows : £ £ Two-fifths thereof to my cousin Mrs. Mary A. Holder (wife *49 of William A. Holder), who resides at Providence in the state of Ehode Island; the balance to be divided equally among my cousin George Stone and his wife Mary Stone who resides at said Providence, and my friend- Fannie Northup (wife of Samuel Northup) who resides at Plainville in the State of Mass.”

Stephen A. Cooke and Louis L. Angelí, for petitioner. George Famed and Frank Famed, for other parties in interest.

¶2 (1) Our opinion is that, under this bequest, the three-fifths of the proceeds of the real estate constituting the balance after payment to Mrs. Holder were taken in equal shares by the legatees named, to wit, George Stone, Mary Stone, his wife, and Fannie Northup. The use of the word “ among ” clearly indicates such an intention. 2 Am. & Eng. Ency. L. 2 ed. 308, note. Moreover, the three persons named all stand on the same footing in the will, and therefore the presumption is that they are to share the bounty of the testatrix equally.

¶3 (2)

¶4 The direction for sale of the homestead estate operated as an equitable conversion of it into personalty, which is deemed to have been made from the time of the testatrix’s decease. King v. King, 13 R. I. 501 (500); Haszard v. Haszard, 19 R. I. 374 (318). It follows that, as Geoi'ge Stone has died since the testatrix, his share is to be treated as personalty and paid to his administrator.