Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

210 Ill. App. 475

Chatelle v. Illinois Central Railroad

Appellate Court of Illinois

Decided April 9, 1918

Appellate Court of Illinois · decided 1918-04-09

<p>Abstract of the Decision.</p> <p>1. Railroads, § 735*—when shown that bell was rung and whistle sounded, on approach to crossing. In an action against a railroad company by an occupant of an automobile to recover for personal injuries received at a highway crossing, due to a collision between one of defendant’s through passenger trains and the automobile, evidence held sufficient to show that the bell of the engine was ringing and the whistle sounding on approaching the crossing.</p> <p>2. Instructions, § 10*—impropriety of giving large number of. It is error for the trial court to give a vast number of instructions amounting in the aggregate to a lengthy address by the court on behalf of defendant.</p> <p>3. Instructions, § 10*—limitation of number. There can be no hard and fast rule limiting the number of instructions.</p> <p>4. Instructions, § 10*—when excessive number given. The giving of thirty-four instructions in behalf of the defendant in a negligence case was error, because of excessiveness.</p> <p>5. Appeal and error—when giving excessive number of instructions is harmless error. The giving of an excessive number of instructions is not reversible error where each instruction is accurate and no other error occurs.</p> <p>6. Railroads, Ü 733*—when freedom from wanton and wilful negligence in operation of train at high speed is shown. In an action by an occupant of an automobile against a railroad company to recover damages for personal injuries sustained in a collision between the automobile and one of defendant’s passenger trains at a highway crossing near the edge of a town, where it appeared .that the train was a through one and was traveling at the rate of 40 to 50 miles per hour, that an ordinance of the town required a speed limit of 10 miles per hour through the town, and the evidence was conflicting as to the giving of statutory signals on approaching the crossing, evidence held to show freedom from wilful and wanton negligence in the operation of the train.</p> <p>7. Appeal and eebob, § 1544*—when plaintiff in negligence case cannot complain of error in instructions. A plaintiff in a negligence case cannot complain because of the submission of the case to the jury with instructions that plaintiff could not recover in the absence of proof of ordinary care, on the ground that the declaration charged wilful and wanton negligence as well as ordinary negligence on the part of defendant, where he did not undertake to submit the question of wilful or wanton negligence, but in two or three of his general instructions covering the case told the jury that they could not find for the plaintiff unless they believed he was in the exercise of ordinary care for his own safety.</p>

Affirmed · Decided 1918-04-09

Mr. Presiding Justice Carnes

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

7. Appeal and eebob, § 1544*—when plaintiff in negligence case cannot complain of error in instructions. A plaintiff in a negligence case cannot complain because of the submission of the case to the jury with instructions that plaintiff could not recover in the absence of proof of ordinary care, on the ground that the declaration charged wilful and wanton negligence as well as ordinary negligence on the part of defendant, where he did not undertake to submit the question of wilful or wanton negligence, but in two or three of his general instructions covering the case told the jury that they could not find for the plaintiff unless they believed he was in the exercise of ordinary care for his own safety.
/210/illapp/475 · .json · Public domain