Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

216 La. 71

43 So.2d 221

Savin v. Savin

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided November 7, 1949

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1949-11-07

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““ * * * if the court shall think it [is] not possible to pronounce definitely on the cause, in the state in which it is, either because the parties have failed to adduce the necessary testimony, or because the inferior court refuse to receive it, or otherwise, it may, according to circumstances, remand the cause to the lower court, with instructions as to the testimony which it shall receive, to the end that it may decide according to law.””

quoted by 1 later decision, including 128 So. 2d 907 - Butler v. American Insurance Co.

“We consider it a condition precedent to the exercise of such authority that we should first determine that it is ‘not possible to pronounce definitely on the cause in the state in which it is,’ —meaning, of course, by ‘definitely’ a judgment according to conscience and the requirements of justice. It is plain that we cannot determine this question without first examining into the merits of the cause * * [ 43 La. Ann. 217 , 9 So. 22 ],”

quoted by 1 later decision, including 128 So. 2d 907 - Butler v. American Insurance Co.

Relies on Mayer v. Barrow · L. A. Frey & Sons, Inc. v. Town of Slidell · Louisiana Ice Manufacturing Co. v. City of New Orleans

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1949-11-07

How this case has been cited

Cited by 16 later decisions — most recently April 1983

16 state decisions

8019491950196019701980decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

HAWTHORNE, Justice.

¶1 Plaintiff-appellant, Dennis Savin, prior to the fixing or hearing of this case on its merits in this court, filed a motion to remand on the ground of newly discovered evidence which he alleges is material to the issues of ■the suit.

¶2 Under the law and the well established jurisprudence of this state, the motion at this time is premature. Code of Practice, Article 906; Louisiana Ice Manufacturing Co. v. City of New Orleans et al., 1891, 43 La.Ann. 217, 9 So. 21; L. A. Frey & Sons, Inc., v. Town of Slidell et ah, 1927, 173 La. 397, 137 So. 193; Mayer v. Barrow et al., 1935, 182 La. 983, 162 So. 748; Alexander v. Jackson, 1940, 195 La. 446, 197 So. 137.

¶3 Article 906 of the Code of Practice provides that we may remand a cause to the lower court if we are of the opinion that it is not possible to pronounce definitively on the cause in the state in which it is, either because the parties have failed to adduce the necessary testimony, or because the inferior court refused to receive it, or otherwise.

¶4 Prior to the submission of this case on its merits, we cannot determine whether it is possible to pronounce definitively on the cause in the state in which it is. In the early case of Louisiana Ice Manufacturing Co. v. City of New Orleans et al., supra [43 La.Ann. 217, 9 So. 22], this court in considering a. motion to remand under the *73 authority of Article 906 of the Code of Practice said: “We consider it a condition precedent to the exercise of such authority that we should first determine that it is ‘not possible to pronounce definitively on the cause in the state in which it is/— meaning, of course, by ‘definitively’ a judgment according to conscience and the requirements of justice. It is plain that we cannot determine this question without first examining into the merits of the cause ■%. iK

¶5 This principle of law has been recognized in each of the other' cases cited above.

¶6 For the reasons assigned, it is ordered that the application to remand be, at the present time, denied, and that the subject matter be referred to the merits of the cause, to be considered and determined when the case is heard and submitted on the merits.

/216/la/71 · .json · Public domain