Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

218 So. 2d 59

Docket No. 2549.

Associate Discount Corp. v. Haviland

ASSOCIATE DISCOUNT CORPORATION, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Chester HAVILAND et al., Clinton "Bill" Bazar, Garnishee, Defendant-Appellee.

Louisiana Court of Appeal

Decided January 16, 1969.

Rehearing Denied February 5, 1969.

Louisiana Court of Appeal · decided 1969-01-16

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““The sheriff shall serve upon the garnishee the citation and a copy of the petition and of the interrogatories, together with a notice that a seizure is thereby effected against any property of or indebtedness to the judgment debtor. “Service shall be made in the manner provided for service of citation, except that if the garnishee is an individual, service must be personal. If the garnishee has concealed or absented himself with the purpose of avoiding personal service, the court may order that service be made in any other manner provided by law. “The garnishee shall file his sworn answers to the interrogatories within fifteen days from the date of service.” (emphasis ours) LSA-C.C.P. art. 2413 reads : “If the garnishee fails to answer within the delay provided by Article 2^12, the judgment creditor may proceed by contradictory motion against the garnishee for the amount of the unpaid judgment, with interest and costs. The failure of the garnishee to answer prior to the filing of such a contradictory motion is prima facie proof that he has property of or is indebted to the judgment debtor to the extent of the judgment, interest, and costs. “Judgment shall be rendered against the garnishee on trial of the motion unless he proves that he had no property of and was not indebted to the judgment debtor. If on the trial of such motion, the garnishee proves the amount of such property or indebtedness, the judgment against the garnishee shall be limited to the delivery of the proper”

quoted by 1 later decision, including 261 So. 2d 708 - Globe Automobile Finance Co. v. Language

“Art. 7. Except as otherwise provided in this article, a party makes a general appearance which subjects him to the jurisdiction of the court and impliedly waives all objections thereto when either personally or through counsel, he seeks therein any relief other than: (1) Entry or removal of the name of an attorney as counsel of record; (2) Extension of time within which to plead; (3) Security for costs; (4) Dissolution of an attachment issued on the ground of the non-residence of the defendant; or (5) Dismissal of the action on the ground that the court has no jurisdiction over the defendant. This article does not apply to an incompetent defendant who attempts to appear personally, or to an absent or incompetent defendant who appears through the attorney at law appointed by the court to represent him. When a defendant files a declinatory exception which includes a prayer for the dismissal of the action on the ground that the court has no jurisdiction over him, the pleading of other objections therein, the filing of the declinatory exception therewith, or the filing of the peremptory exception or an answer therewith when required by law, does not constitute a general appearance.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Mid-City Investment Co. v. Young

Relies on Stanley v. Jones · Baton Rouge Bldg. Trades Council v. T. L. James & Co. · 135 So. 2d 594 - Forbess v. George Morgan Pontiac Company

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1969-01-16

How this case has been cited

Cited by 9 later decisions — most recently May 2013

9 state decisions

30196919701980199020002010decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1Dragon & Kellner, by Robert A. Dragon, Jr., Lafayette, for plaintiff-appellant.

¶2*60 Tate & Tate, by Donald J. Tate, Mamou, for defendant-appellee.

¶3Before FRUGÉ, SAVOY, and HOOD, JJ.

¶4FRUGÉ, Judge.

¶5On May 9, 1968, Associate Discount Corporation, the judgment creditor of Chester Haviland, instituted garnishment proceedings against Clinton "Bill" Bazar, the employer of Chester Haviland, the judgment debtor. The original judgment was in the amount of $1,883.82, with eight percent interest per annum from November 6, 1965 until paid, plus twenty-five percent of the interest as attorneys' fees and all costs. Plaintiff filed a petition for garnishment naming the judgment debtor's employer, Clinton "Bill" Bazar, as the garnishee. The petition was personally served on Mr. Bazar on May 11, 1968.

¶6Upon service, Clinton Bazar warned Chester Haviland that his employment would be terminated unless suitable arrangements were made with the creditor. After taking time off from work supposedly to confer with the creditor, Haviland returned and assured defendant that the garnishment was suspended and that arrangements had been made. As a result, defendant failed to answer interrogatories attached to the petition of garnishment until June 12, 1968, when he learned of the filing of a "Motion for Judgment Pro Confesso" by the creditor on June 11, 1968. This motion sought judgment against defendant for the entire amount of the debt, plus attorney's fees for the rule of $110.00, all under Article 2413 of the Louisiana Code of Civil Procedure (1960).

¶7After answering the interrogatories on June 12, 1968, defendant, Clinton Bazar, filed a "Motion to Deny Attorney's Fees to Seizing Creditor and to Fix Attorney's Fee of Garnishee". In the motion, he placed principal reliance upon the following as defenses against the garnishment petition.

1) The misnomer of the defendant as "Bill" Bazar, instead of his real name, Clinton Bazar, "Bill" being only a nickname.
2) Defective citation and petition.
3) Estoppel (Defendant's having been assured that arrangements had been made).

¶8The trial court, after hearing evidence on both motions, dismissed the plaintiff's suit at his cost, and denied defendant attorney's fees. From this ruling, the plaintiff has appealed.

¶9In its specification of error, plaintiff alleges that the trial court erred in finding that it was estopped from holding the garnishee responsible in this matter because it used a wrong name for the garnishee in the petition. Further, that the trial court erred in dismissing the entire matter at its cost.

¶10Before getting to a discussion of the actual issues, we note that the record reveals that the defendant, Bill Bazar, did pay the judgment debtor, Chester Haviland, the sum of $150.00 after receipt of the petition of garnishment and interrogatories. It was also brought out on the trial of the motions that the judgment debtor, Chester Haviland, owed defendant the amount of $28.80.

¶11In deciding this case, the court notes a number of possible issues, but only three of which are significant; namely, the issue as to waiver of improper citation and service, untimely answer to the petition and interrogatories, and the question as to the merits.

¶12Of these more narrow issues, we shall discuss each separately.

¶131) Waiver.

¶14Defendant claims that he was never properly before the court, even after answer to *61 the interrogatories, because the answer to the interrogatories is not a "pleading" under an interpretation of C.C.P. Art. 1312, Comment (d).[1] Furthermore, his "answer" sought no "relief" under Article 7, so again there was no appearance.

¶15With the above propositions, we shall not wrestle, for the simple reason that we feel the motion filed by defendant entitled "Motion to Deny Attorney's Fee to Seizing Creditor and to Fix Attorney's Fee of Garnishee", did constitute an appearance, did ask for relief, and under the jurisprudence of this state, did constitute a waiver of any objections to the presence of the defendant before the court and a general appearance under C.C.P. Article 7. Of significance here, we quote from one of the averments from said motion, namely Number 6:

"That the fee of the garnishee's attorney for appearing in this court in answer to the defective Rule taken against garnishee, pursuant to defective garnishment process, is approximately $75.00, and his fee for answering the Interrogatories and corresponding with the attorney for the seizing creditor is approximately, $50.00."

¶16The pertinent part of C.C.P. Article 7 reads as follows:

"… [A] party makes a general appearance which subjects him to the jurisdiction of the court and impliedly waives all objections thereto when, either personally or through counsel, he seeks therein any relief other than …."

¶17The request by defendant for attorney's fees is not among the request for relief allowable under the article as not constituting an appearance. Therefore, under the jurisprudence, this request for attorney's fees was fatal to defendant's objections as to improper citation, improper petition, or generally the presence of the defendant before the court.

¶18In the case of Doll v. Mallard, 95 So.2d 692 (Orl.La.App., 1957), the court had this to say:

"It is well settled in our jurisprudence that when one who has not been properly served with citation or upon whom there was no service voluntarily makes his appearance in the case, he thereby waives any right to object to the insufficiency of citation or the lack of it." (P. 693).

¶19The above principle of procedural law has been observed and followed in numerous cases, among which we cite: Baton Rouge Building Trades Council v. T. L. James & Co., 201 La. 749, 10 So.2d 606 (1942); Stanley v. Jones, 197 La. 627, 2 So.2d 45 (1941); and the now famous case of Forbess v. George Morgan Pontiac Company, 135 So. 2d 594 (La.App. 2d Cir., 1961), wherein it was held that a request for damages, in an attempt to dissolve an attachment, constituted a general appearance and subjected the defendant to the jurisdiction of the court. Of this case, the late Dean Henry G. McMahon in 23 La.L.Rev. 378 at 381 (1963) had this to say:

"… The writer completely agrees with the majority holding that, by seeking the recovery of damages for the illegal issuance of the attachment, the defendant submitted to the jurisdiction of the court. This result is called for by the specific language of the general appearance article of the new Code [Art. 7], which provides. … A defendant makes a general appearance whenever he affirmatively invokes the jurisdiction of the court. …" (Emphasis supplied.)

¶20By asking for attorney's fees, the defendant did affirmatively invoke the jurisdiction of the court, and therefore, we *62 feel, made a general appearance, and subjected himself to the jurisdiction of the court and impliedly waived all objections to citation, misnomer of defendant, or improper petition.

¶212) The failure of the defendant to answer the garnishment petition timely.[2]

¶22Because the lower court ruled that the defendant was never properly before the court, it was not confronted with the issue as to what remedy was due the plaintiff, in view of the admitted failure of the defendant to timely answer the garnishment petition.

¶23As to what must be done, we note articles 2412 and 2413 of the C.C.P. (1960). Article 2412, the last paragraph, states, "The garnishee shall file his sworn answers to the interrogatories within fifteen days from the date of service." (Emphasis added.) This article makes it mandatory that the answer be filed within fifteen days of service and since it is admitted that the answers were not filed until June 12, one month after receipt by defendant of the petition and interrogatories, automatically the provisions of Article 2413 are invoked.

¶24Article 2413 is entitled "Effect of garnishee's failure to answer". In this article, we note the following pertinent language:

"If the garnishee fails to answer within the delay provided by Article 2412, the judgment creditor may proceed by contradictory motion against the garnishee for the amount of the unpaid judgment, with interest and costs. …
"Judgment shall be rendered against the garnishee on trial of the motion unless he proves that he had no property of and was not indebted to the judgment debtor. If on the trial of such motion, the garnishee proves the amount of such property, or indebtedness, the judgment against the garnishee shall be limited to the delivery of the property or payment of the indebtedness, as provided in Article 2415.
"Regardless of the decision on the contradictory motion, the court shall render judgment against the garnishee for the costs and a reasonable attorney's fee for the motion." (Emphasis ours.)

¶25From this article, we denote that it is mandatory that plaintiff be awarded reasonable attorney's fees and cost for the motion filed by plaintiff because of garnishee's failure to timely answer the petition. As well, the court may decide that the defendant is liable for the total judgment. In any case, the lower court must award plaintiff reasonable attorney's fees and cost of the motion, and we hereby remand this case for the determination of the amount of said fees and cost to be awarded plaintiff, and for a determination as to defendant's liability for the entire judgment, interest and cost.

¶263) As to the merits.

¶27Having decided that the defendant is properly before the court, a ruling which constitutes a reversal of the lower court, it is the opinion of the court that this case, as concerns the merits, will have to be remanded to the lower court. For determination by the lower court are the questions as to the amount wrongly paid to the judgment-debtor by the defendant, the amount of the exempt portion of the wages, the amount and manner in which, if provable, the indebtedness to the employer is to be paid him, and the award to the creditor from said wages paid. In addition, the amount of attorney's fees and cost already noted as due the plaintiff, will have to be set.

¶28For the foregoing reasons, the judgment of the lower court is found to be erroneous and said judgment, dismissing plaintiff's *63 petition at his cost, is hereby reversed. The entire case is remanded to the lower court for the determinations as above noted, and for further proceedings not inconsistent with the views herein expressed. All costs so far incurred to be paid by defendant-garnishee.

¶29Reversed and remanded.

NOTES

¶30[1] Defendant's argument is that since the comment says that the interrogatories are not "pleadings", then the answer to the interrogatories is not a "pleading"—therefore, he never made an appearance because of the answer.

¶31[2] This case represents another one of those unfortunate situations in which the client waited too long to seek the advice of an attorney. Had the client done so at an earlier time, this entire matter would probably never have arisen.

/218/so2d/59 · .json · Public domain