Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

22 Tex. 282

Luckie v. McGlasson

Texas Supreme Court

Decided July 1, 1858

Texas Supreme Court · decided 1858-07-01

Tried below before the E[on. Fielding Jones. Suit brought on a promissory note, by the appellee. Defence, failure of consideration. Exceptions by the plaintiff, to the sufficiency of the plea; exceptions sustained. Judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant, Samuel Luckie, as maker of said note, and John C. McKean and John T. Tinsley, the endorsers.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently December 1923

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1858-07-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Roberts, J.

¶1The only question in this case, is, was the plea of -failure of consideration, a defence to the action on the note given as the purchase money of the land sold to appellant, by Tinsley and McKean, assignors of McGlasson ?

¶2It alleges that, at the time of the sale, said Tinsley and McKean “fraudulently and falsely represented to this defendant, that they had a valid title to said land; and they stipulated with this defendant for a deed in fee simple, with a full “warranty of title, against all persons whatsoever;” that they had no title, and have acquired none since; and that the title to said land is in John Davis.

¶3The defects of this plea are, 1st. It does not state that the representations, however false and fraudulent, were relied on in the purchase, and did actually deceive the defendant. (Moreland v. Atchison, 19 Tex. Rep. 303.) 2d. It does not state such facts, as certainly put Tinsley and McKean in default, in not making a title. The allegations leave it uncertain, whether a deed was made or not. And if they be construed to allege that a deed was not made, but only an obligation, with certain “stipulations” for title, then those stipulations are not set forth, so as to show under what terms, conditions and limitations, as to time, payments and the like, the contract of sale was made. Such stipulations should have been stated, so that it might appear *285that their non-performance, or the inability to perform them, would put said Tinsley and McKean in default. (Cooper v. Singleton, 19 Tex. Kep. 260; Lawrence v. Simonton, 13 Id. 220.) The plea is therefore insufficient.

¶4Judgment affirmed.

/22/tex/282 · .json · Public domain