¶1(Dissenting). The definite question to be considered is clearly stated in the majority opinion in these words: “May the Arkansas Courts entertain a suit
¶2Insofar as Barton’s defense against the Planters Flying Service is concerned, the Arkansas Court has jurisdiction.
¶3In Western Union Tel. Co. v. Bush, 191 Ark. 1085, 89 S. W. 2d 723, 103 A. L. R. 367, we held that damage to a growing crop was a damage to real property, and that an action to recover such damage MUST be brought in the County in which the land is situated.
¶4The majority in the present case candidly admits that every American Jurisdiction — save only the State of Minnesota — has followed the holding in the original case of Livingston v. Jefferson (1811) 1 Brock. 203, Fed. Cas. No. 8, 411; yet the majority, in seeing fit to depart from such time honored holding, advances three reasons, which do not seem to me to be sufficient for such a radical departure.
¶5In the first place, the majority says that we have ample facilities to determine the land laws of other States in the United States. Here is the wording of the majority-opinion: “In our library, we have the statutes and decisions of every other State, and it seldom takes more than a few hours to find the answer to a particular question.” This statement about the size of the law library seems rather weak, because land actions are tried in lower courts and not in the Supreme Court library. Just because we have a fine law library does not mean that we are prepared to determine the title to lands in Texas,
¶6Secondly, the majority says that the rule, requiring that an action be brought in the jurisdiction in which the land is situated, is a good rule between Nations, but is not good as between States in the American Union. For answer to this, I say: I have always understood that each of the American States is Sovereign; that the Federal Government is a government of delegated powers; and that all powers not delegated to the Federal Government are retained by the States and the People.
¶7Thirdly, the majority says that it does not desire to afford Arkansas Citizens a sanctuary from damage actions by citizens of other States. This is an argument that should be made — if at all — in the Legislative branch of Government, rather than in a judicial opinion. It is for the Legislative Department to determine when and where actions may be prosecuted. The opinion of the majority in the case at bar is therefore judicial legislation, minus only the enacting clause required of legislative determinations.
¶8And having briefly noticed the three arguments advanced by the majority for the departure from the holding of the vast array of sister jurisdictions, I desire now to call attention to the Annotation in 42 A. L. R. 196, entitled “Jurisdiction of action at law for damages for tort concerning real property in another state or country ’ \
“Generally speaking, actions for injuries to personal property or personal right may be brought wherever the defendant may be found and served, but at common law the courts of one state or country are without jurisdiction in actions that are local in their nature, and relate to subjects within another state or country. 7 R. C. L. 1058, 1059, Secs. ,96, 97. Therefore, in the absence of a statute specifically limiting or enlarging jurisdiction of local courts, the principal question in every case involving matters occurring in another jurisdiction is whether the action is local, or transitory in its nature. According to the generally accepted view, if the principal fact carries with it the idea of some certain place, — -for example, relates to land, — it is local, as the distinction between local and transitory actions exists in the nature of the subject injured, and-not in the means used or the place where the injury took place.”
¶9Because of the views herein stated, I respectfully dissent from the majority in the case at bar; and I am authorized to state that Mr. Justice Ward concurs in this dissent.
¶10 This means an action at law for damages, rather than “a suit”.
¶11 The Planters Flying Service brought action against Barton to collect the account for spraying his cotton crop. Barton defended against the action by claiming that the insecticide was not as represented. The Arkansas Court had jurisdiction of this action because it was an action on account and was transitory.
¶12 The scholarly opinion of Mr. Justice Baker in that case is worthy of study.
¶13 The writer knows by experience that only one skilled in Texas Land Law can successfully handle an action of Trespass to try title in the State of Texas.
¶14 See Amendment No. 10 to United States Constitution.
¶15 For study, in addition to cases in the above Annotation, see Leflar on Conflict of Laws, Sec. 4, and Sec. 82. See also American Law Institute’s Restatement of Conflict of Laws, § 614, et seq.
¶16 Proverbs 22:28, “Remove not the ancient landmark, which thy fathers have set.”