Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

225 So. 3d 1053

State v. Johnson

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided September 6, 2017

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 2017-09-06

Decided 2017-09-06

¶1ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE COURT OF APPEAL, FIRST CIRCUIT, PARISH OF ASSUMPTION

¶2Writ denied.

GENOVESE, J.,

¶3would grant and assigns reasons:

¶4h Defendant was tried and convicted by a six-person jury for a felony punishable at hard labor. The Louisiana Constitution states: “A case in which the punishment is necessarily confinement at hard labor shall be tried before a jury of twelve persons, ten of whom must concur to render a verdict.” La.Const. art. 1, § 17(A). Additionally, this constitutional mandate is codified in La.Code Crim.P. art. 782(A) which states: “Cases in which punishment is necessarily confinement at hard labor shall be tried by a jury composed of twelve jurors, ten of whom must concur to render a verdict.”

¶5Thus, it is crystal clear that a felony punishable at hard labor shall be tried by a twelve-person jury, not a six-person jury. The word “shall” is mandatory. This error is structural. A constitutional and legislative mandate cannot be sluffed off as harmless error. I would grant this writ to correct the structural error.

/225/so3d/1053 · .json · Public domain