Forbes v. Eagleson’s Empirical Analysis

Citation profile

16 federal appellate · 9 district · 1 state decisions

Most-quoted passages

The sentences later courts lift from this opinion, ranked by how many decisions quote each — the parts of the opinion doing the work. These counts are smaller than the citation total above because most of the 70 citing decisions cite the case generally; a passage count includes only decisions quoting that exact language verbatim.

1. “we must determine when the plaintiffs knew or should have known of their injury.”

   4 later decisions quote this exact passage · from the majority
   e.g. Karen Cetel Morton Schneider Marvin Cetel Marvin Cetel, M.D., P.A. Barbara Schneider Barbara Schneider, M.D., F.A.C.S., P.A. v. Kirwan Financial Group, Inc. Barry Cohen Michael Kirwan Neil Prupis Lampf, Lipkind, Prupis, Petigrow & Labue Raymond G. Ankner Cja Associates Beaven Companies, Inc. Medical Society of New Jersey Inter-American Insurance Co. Of Illinois Commonwealth Life Insurance Co. Peoples Security Life Insurance Co. Monumental Life Insurance Co. Capital Holding Company Aegon Insurance Group Indianapolis Life Insurance Co. (District of New Jersey Civil No. 00-Cv-5799). Vijay Sankhla, M.D., on Behalf of Himself and Others Similarly Situated v. Commonwealth Life Insurance Company Peoples Security Life Insurance Company Providian Life Insurance Company Aegon USA Inc. Monumental Life Insurance Company Indianapolis Life Insurance Co. Raymond G. Ankner Beaven Companies, Inc. Cja and Associates Kirwan Financial Group, Inc. Kirwan Financial Advisory, Inc. Barry Cohen Michael Kirwan Pacific Executive Services Stephen R. Ross Donald S. Murphy Sea Nine Associate Dsm, Inc. New Jersey Medical Profession Association Southern California Medical Profession Association the Medical Society of New Jersey Neil Prupis. (District of New Jersey Civil No. 01-Cv-04781) Vijay Sankhla, M.D., Yale Shulman, M.D., Yale Shulman, M.D., P.A., Boris Pearlman, M.D. Denville Radiology, P.A., Marvin Cetel, M.D., Karen Cetel, Marvin Cetel, M.D., P.A., Barbara Schneider, M.D., Morton Schneider, Barbara Schneider, M.D. P.A., (Pursuant to Rule 12(a), f.r.a.p.). Karen Cetel Morton Schneider Marvin Cetel Marvin Cetel, M.D., P.A. Barbara Schneider Barbara Schneider, M.D., F.A.C.S., P.A. v. Kirwan Financial Group, Inc. Barry Cohen Michael Kirwan Neil Prupis Lampf, Lipkind, Prupis, Petigrow & Labue Raymond G. Ankner Cja Associates Beaven Companies, Inc. Medical Society of New Jersey Inter-American Insurance Co. Of Illinois Commonwealth Life Insurance Co. Peoples Security Life Insurance Co. Monumental Life Insurance Co. Capital Holding Company Aegon Insurance Group Indianapolis Life Insurance Co. (District of New Jersey Civil No. 00-Cv-5799). Vijay Sankhla, M.D., on Behalf of Himself and Others Similarly Situated v. Commonwealth Life Insurance Company Peoples Security Life Insurance Company Providian Life Insurance Company Aegon USA Inc. Monumental Life Insurance Company Indianapolis Life Insurance Co. Raymond G. Ankner Beaven Companies, Inc. Cja and Associates Kirwan Financial Group, Inc. Kirwan Financial Advisory, Inc. Barry Cohen Michael Kirwan Pacific Executive Services Stephen R. Ross Donald S. Murphy Sea Nine Associate Dsm, Inc. New Jersey Medical Profession Association Southern California Medical Profession Association the Medical Society of New Jersey Neil Prupis. (District of New Jersey Civil No. 01-Cv-04781). Marvin Cetel, M.D., Karen Cetel, Marvin Cetel, M.D., P.A., Barbara Schneider, M.D., Morton Schneider, Barbara Schneider, M.D. P.A., Karen Cetel Morton Schneider Marvin Cetel Marvin Cetel, M.D., P.A. Barbara Schneider Barbara Schneider, M.D., F.A.C.S., P.A. v. Kirwan Financial Group, Inc. Barry Cohen Michael Kirwan Neil Prupis Lampf, Lipkind, Prupis, Petigrow & Labue Raymond G. Ankner Cja Associates Beaven Companies, Inc. Medical Society of New Jersey Inter-American Insurance Co. Of Illinois Commonwealth Life Insurance Co. Peoples Security Life Insurance Co. Monumental Life Insurance Co. Capital Holding Company Aegon Insurance Group Indianapolis Life Insurance Co. (District of New Jersey Civil No. 00-Cv-5799). Vijay Sankhla, M.D., on Behalf of Himself and Others Similarly Situated v. Commonwealth Life Insurance Company Peoples Security Life Insurance Company Providian Life Insurance Company Aegon USA Inc. Monumental Life Insurance Company Indianapolis Life Insurance Co. Raymond G. Ankner Beaven Companies, Inc. Cja and Associates Kirwan Financial Group, Inc. Kirwan Financial Advisory, Inc. Barry Cohen Michael Kirwan Pacific Executive Services Stephen R. Ross Donald S. Murphy Sea Nine Associate Dsm, Inc. New Jersey Medical Profession Association Southern California Medical Profession Association the Medical Society of New Jersey Neil Prupis. (District of New Jersey Civil No. 01-Cv-04781). Donald S. Murphy, Pacific Executive Services, Dsm, Inc., Karen Cetel Morton Schneider Marvin Ceten Marvin Cetel, M.D., P.A. Barbara Schneider Barbara Schneider, M.D., F.A.C.S., P.A. v. Kirwan Financial Group, Inc. Barry Cohen Michael Kirwan Neil Prupis Lampf, Lipkind, Prupis, Petigrow & Labue Raymond G. Ankner Cja Associates Beaven Companies, Inc. Medical Society of New Jersey Inter-American Insurance Co. Of Illinois Commonwealth Life Insurance Co. Peoples Security Life Insurance Co. Monumental Life Insurance Co. Capital Holding Company Aegon Insurance Group Indianapolis Life Insurance Co. (District of New Jersey Civil No. 00-Cv-5799). Vijay Sankhla, M.D., on Behalf of Himself and Others Similarly Situated v. Commonwealth Life Insurance Company Peoples Security Life Insurance Company Providian Life Insurance Company Aegon USA Inc. Monumental Life Insurance Company Indianapolis Life Insurance Co. Raymond G. Ankner Beaven Companies, Inc. Cja and Associates Kirwan Financial Group, Inc. Kirwan Financial Advisory, Inc. Barry Cohen Michael Kirwan Pacific Executive Services Stephen R. Ross Donald S. Murphy Sea Nine Associate Dsm, Inc. New Jersey Medical Profession Association Southern California Medical Profession Association the Medical Society of New Jersey Neil Prupis. (District of New Jersey Civil No. 01-Cv-04781). Monumental Life Insurance Company, Commonwealth Life Insurance Company, Capital Holding Corporation, and Aegon Usa, Inc. · Mathews v. Kidder, Peabody & Co.

2. “[A] court must determine (1) whether there is sufficient evidence to support a finding that defendants engaged in affirmative acts of concealment designed to mislead the plaintiffs regarding facts supporting their ... claim, (2) whether there is sufficient evidence to support a finding that plaintiffs exercised reasonable diligence, and (3) whether there is sufficient evidence to support a -finding that plaintiffs • were not aware, nor should they have been aware, of the facts supporting their claim until a time within the limitations period measured backwards from when the plaintiffs filed their complaint.””

   3 later decisions quote this exact passage · from the majority
   e.g. In re Blood Reagents Antitrust Litigation · William Bailey, Jr. v. Viacom Inc

3. “active misleading by the defendant and ... that he exercised reasonable diligence in attempting to uncover the relevant facts.”

   2 later decisions quote this exact passage · from the majority
   e.g. Mathews v. Kidder, Peabody & Co. · USX Corp. v. Barnhart