Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

23 F. Cas. 593

The Syracuse

U.S. District Court

Decided November 27, 1867

U.S. District Court · decided 1867-11-27

<p>Case No. 13,717.</p> <p>Towage — Contkact — Negligence — New Yoke Hakbok.</p> <p>1. A contract by a steamer to tow a canal boat, at the risk of the canal boat, does not exempt the steamboat from liability for damages caused to the canal boat by the negligence of those in charge of the steamboat.</p> <p>[Cited in The M. J. Cummings. 18 Fed. 183; The Packer, 28 Fed. 158; The Jonty Jenks, 04 Fed. 1023.]</p> <p>2. Where a steamboat, with thirty-five boats in tow, is endeavoring to nass around the Battery, at New York, from the North river into the Bast river, she should, if the harbor is crowded with vessels at anchor, pass around Governor’s Island, and come up into the Bast river through Buttermilk channel.</p> <p>[On appeal to the supreme court, the judgment of the circuit court was affirmed. 12 Wall. (79 U. S.) 167.]</p>

Decided 1867-11-27

NELSON. Circuit Justice.

¶1One ground of defence set up is. that, by the contract of towage, it was agreed that the canal boat was to be towed by the steamer at her own risk. The answei to this is, that this contract does not exempt the steamboat from liability for damages caused to the canal boat by the negligence of those in charge of the steamboat.

¶2On the question of negligence, the court oelow decided against the steamboat, in ac*594cordance, X think, with the weight of the evidence. The steamboat was making the circuit to get into the East river, the tide being ebb. The weight of the proof is, that chere was room sufficient, with the exercise of proper caution and care, to make the turn with safety, and avoid vessels at anchor. Besides, even conceding the crowded condition of the harbor, the steamboat should have followed the precaution of one which, with as large a tow. thirty-five boats, had gone down just ahead of her, and. to avoid danger, had passed around Governor’s Island, and come up into the East river through Buttermilk channel. Decree affirmed.

[On appeal to the supreme court, the judgment of the circuit court was affirmed. 12 Wall. (79 U. S.) 167.]
/23/fcas/593 · .json · Public domain