Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

23 How. Pr. 1

Livingston v. Swift

New York Supreme Court

Decided December 15, 1861

New York Supreme Court · decided 1861-12-15

The leading facts are as follows : An order was made in this action, on an affidavit on behalf of plaintiff’s assignor, by which the judge appointed E. Newcomb, Esq. to take the examination of defendant and return the same to the judge. The order contained the usual restraining clause forbidding a transfer or other disposition of the property of the judgment debtor not exempt from execution, and any interference therewith.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1861-12-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 6 later decisions — most recently December 1933

6 state decisions

2018611870188018901900191019201930decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1By the court,

Hogeboom, Justice.

¶2I think Judge Wolford’s order discharging defendant, erroneous.

¶31. Whether the defendant was served with the injunction order in due form or not, by the exhibition of the original, is a disputed question of fact upon which the judge had a right to pass. But I think knowledge of the injunction, information of its contents, presence in court when it was made, would be fully sufiicient to impose upon the defendant the duty of obeying it, at least so far as the pecuniary rights of the relator are concerned. (Hull agt. Thomas, 3 Edw. Ch. Rep., 236; People ex rel. Morrison agt. Brewer, 4 *3Paige, 405; Stafford agt. Brown, 4 Paige, 360; People agt. Compton, 1 Duer, 563, overruling or questioning Coddington agt. Webb, 4 S. S. C. R., 639; People agt. Sturtevant, 5 Seld., 278.)

¶4Whether, to make out a case of wilful and intentional disrespect to the process of the judge, so as to require him to punish for a criminal contempt of the dignity and authority of the court, the service should be by showing the original order, is not necessary to be considered. (1 Barb. Ch. Pr., 639; Code, § 302; Coddington agt. Webb, 4 S. S. C. R., 639; 3 Cl. Dig., 3106.)

¶5The cases are entirely distinct as to the remedy and the nature and object of the punishment, where a party’s pecuniary rights have been affected or impaired. By a disobedience of the process or order of the court or officer, the court or judge has no discretion, but must impose a fine sufficient to indemnify the party. (2 R. S., 538; People agt. Compton, 1 Duer, 515.) Where the dignity of the court has been assailed and treated with contempt, the court or judge is the guardian of its own dignity, and sole judge both as to the facts of the offence and amount of fine or imprisonment (within the statutory limits) requisite to vindicate its honor and dignity. (Mitchell’s case, 12 Abb., 249: Reynolds agt. McElhone, 20 How., 454.) As the evidence established an unquestionable case of contempt to the prejudice of the relator to the amount of the property received in violation of the injunction, it was imperative to punish the party to that extent.

¶62. The order was plainly appealable by the relator. It affected a substantial right, to his prejudice. He was substantially a party to the proceeding, and the non-conviction for the contempt and non-imposition of a fine was a direct damage to him to the extent of the money clearly received.

¶73. As the nature and the amount of the punishment to be imposed was (beyond the limits which we have named) *4a matter of discretion with the officer, it is not perhaps appropriate that this court should attempt, on reversing this order, to make such order as the court below ought to have made, but leave the parties concerned to such future proceedings to vindicate and enforce their rights as they shall be advised.

¶8The order of the county judge of Albany county should be reversed, with ten dollars costs to be paid by the respondent to the appellant, and without prejudice to the appellant to institute such further proceedings on account of the disobedience of the injunction order as he shall be advised.

/23/howpr/1 · .json · Public domain