Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

23 La. Ann. 354

George v. Knox

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided April 15, 1871

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1871-04-15

<p>Tlie vendor wlio wishes to avail himself of the action to rescind the sale of real estate, on tlie ground that tlie vendee has not complied with the condition of the sale by paying the installments at maturity, must show that he has returned to the vendee, or offered to return, that portion of the price which ho has received. This offer to return the portion of the price which he has received must be made before suit is brought to rescind the sale. This preliminary stop of the vendor cannot be avoided by his showing that the rents and revenues of the property were worth more than the amount he had received in part payment of the price, because, from tlie date of the sale, the title and ownership of the property passed to tlie vendee, and the rents and revenues thereof belonged to him. and not to the vendor.</p> <p>Ad agreement made by the attorney of the vendor with the curator ad hoc, who represented the vendee in a suit to rescind the sale, to tho effect that the vendee was to tako the rents and revenues of the properly during the time that he had it in possession asan equivalent for the part of the price which lie had already paid, is not binding on the vendee because the curator ad lwc, by virtue of his appointment as such, is not authorized to make such agreement.</p>

Relies on Janin v. Franklin · Barrett v. Bullard

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1871-04-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 16 later decisions — most recently February 2001

1 district · 14 state decisions

4018711880189019001910192019301940195019601970198019902000decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Lubering, C. J.

¶1This is an action for the resolution of a sale for the non-payment of tlie price.

¶2. In November, 1855, tlie plaintiff sold to Knox a plantation for $34,000, payable in installments as follows : Four thousand dollars on the first day of March, 1856; three thousand dollars on tlie first day of March, 1857; and a like sum annually thereafter until the first of March, 1865,

¶3*355Tlio first two installments, amounting to $7000, were paid at their maturity; tho other notes are still unpaid.

¶4Citations in this suit were acknowledged on the eighteenth and twenty-second of May, 1868.

¶5The note maturing on the first of March, 1858, was not paid. At that moment, the purchaser having failed to comply with Ms engagement, the resolutory condition, implied in all commutative contracts, took c-ifect, and the seller had a right to sue for the dissolution of the sale. C. C. 2015, 25C1.

¶6And from the period when the seller had the right to sue to dissolve tho sale for the non-payment of the price, prescription began to run against that right; therefore the action was barred by the prescription of ton years, when it was instituted in May, 1868. C. C., 3508; 11 An. 656, George v. Lewis; 14 An. 340, Thompson v. Gelcnore.

¶7Besides, it appears from the allegations of the plaintiff’s petition, that ho has received $7000 of the price, and this money he has not restored or offered to restore to the purchaser. He cannot keep the price and claim the property which was sold. 4 La. 198; 19 La. 281; 9 R. 306; 2 An. 389; 4 An. 562; 21 An. 425.

¶8The plaintiff contends that the price received by him was compensated by the rents andrevenues of tho place while in the possession of tlie vendee, and he relies upon an agreement entered into between himself and tlie curator ad hoc, appointed to represent Knox, an absentee, which is as follows :

¶9“ It is agreed between the parties, plaintiff and defendant, first, that tho plaintiff waives and renounces all claim or interest in and for rents and revenues claimed in the petition for the use and occupation of the lands or plantation by the defendants and their vendees, after their purchase from tho plaintiff, and it is agreed, in the second place, that in consideration of the above remuneration on the part of the plaintiff, that the defendants hereby relinquish and renounce any and all claims for the repayment of any money or moneys they may have at any time paid said plaintiff for and in part payment of the price of the land, the sale of which is sought to be dissolved and rescinded bv this suit. This -day of October, 1868,

¶10(Signed) “ M. DuBOSE, Attorney for Plaintiff.

¶11“ ED. IP. NEWMAN, Curator ad hocP

¶12The curator ad hoc had not the authority to make such an agreement, and even if he could lawfully have entered into it, it did not bind the estate of McNeil, the vendee of Knox, and the real defendant. The fruits of property belonged to the owner thereof, and the vendee was the owner of the property, and not the vendor.

¶13It is therefore ordered and adjudged that tho judgment of the district court be affirmed with costs of appeal.

Howe, J.,

¶14concurring. I do not think this action, is prescribed; but I concur on the second ground which forms the basis of the opinion of the court.

/23/laann/354 · .json · Public domain