Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

23 Mass. 460

Allen v. Bates

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided September 26, 1828

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1828-09-26

<p>Whit of entry sur disseisin. The tenants offered in evidence, in support of their title, a deed from J. W. Smith to Z. Lyman, of “ a certain tract of land lying in South Hadley, with the buildings thereon standing; further reference had at the register’s office, book no. 51, page 257.” At the place referred to was the record of a deed dated February 21, 1824, from Willis Pease to Smitn, of “the right to lay out m Thomas Hovey’s 2d choice in the two thousand acre division, nine acres of the common and undivided land in South Hadley or Granby in the county aforesaid, which Thomas Moody of said Granby conveyed to me by a deed dated the 28th day of Aug. A. D. 1821.” The tenants produced also the Proprietors’ Records of South Hadley and Granby, in which was the following entry. “ Part of Thomas Hovey’s second choice in the 2000 acre division laid out to Willis Pease on the mountain west of Taylor’s Crack, beginning &c., nine acres, surveyed August 28th, 1821, per Gardner Preston, surveyor.” The tenants also proved by a witness, that the land so laid out was the same with the demanded premises, and with that intended to be conveyed by Smith’s deed. The demandant objected to the admission of these deeds as being void for uncertainty, and to the paroi evidence so offered to explain and support them.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently July 1897

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1828-09-26

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1But the Court held that the description in the deed from Smith to Lyman was made sufficiently certain by reference,1 and that the paroi evidence was properly admitted ;2 and judgment was given according to the verdict, which was for the tenants.

¶2 See Brown v. Bellows, 4 Pick. (2nd ed.) 190, note 2; Foss v. Crisp, 20 Pick. 121.

¶3 See 2 Stark. Ev. (5th Am ed.) 560, 561, note 1.

/23/mass/460 · .json · Public domain