Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

23 N.C. 145

Lewis v. Smith

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided June 15, 1840

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1840-06-15

<p>Where a testator bequeathed certain slaves to one for life, and then over to another person, and the legatee for life, -without any renunciation of record by the executors named in the will, obtained letters of administration with the will annexed, upon the estate, and took possession of the slaves, and retained them for more than thirty years, until his death, it was held, that the jury might infer an assent of the executors,' or make any other reasonable presumption of fact, to uphold the right of the legatee in remainder.</p> <p>The interest in an executory devise or bequest is transmissible to the" heirs or executor of one dying before the happening of the contingency upon which it depends.</p>

Decided 1840-06-15

Gaston, Judge.

¶1We are satified with his Honor’s charge to the jury, and see no cause to reverse the judgment in this

¶2case. It may indeed have been'well questioned whether William Kemp, or the representatives of William Kemp, alter he had obtained letters oí administration with the will, annexed of Joseph Kemp, and had acted as such administrator without question during the lives of the persons therein nominated as executors, could be received to object that he was not administrator, because there was no renunciation of the executors of record; but however this might be, if William Kemp did (in the language of the Judge) “elect to hold the negroes as a legatee under the will of Joseph Kemp,” the court and jury were justified in any reasonable presumption of fact, after an undisturbed possession for thirty-three years, and until the expiration of his interest in the legacy, to uphold the right of the legatees in remainder under the same will.

¶3The second question raised is free from doubt. The interest in an executory devise or bequest is transmissible to the heir or executor of one dying before the happening of the contingency upon which it depends. Let the judgment be affirmed.

¶4Pee. Curiam. Judgment affirmed,.

/23/nc/145 · .json · Public domain