¶1E. Curtis Schwab, Jr., for appellant.
¶2William B. Hopkins (Claude D. Carter, Martin, Hopkins, Lemon & Carter, P.C., Roanoke, on brief), for appellees, Edna Moran and Lemon & Lambdon, Inc.
¶3No brief or argument for appellee, Norris & Jones Const. Co., Inc.
¶4Present: All the Justices.
¶5COMPTON, Justice.
¶6In 1977, as part of the revision of the general laws of Virginia relating to civil remedies and procedure, the General Assembly enacted Code §§ 8.01-243 and -248, dealing with statutes of limitation. Section 8.01-243 provides:
"Personal action for injury to person or property generally.ÂA. Unless otherwise provided by statute, every action for personal injuries, whatever the theory of recovery, except as provided in B. hereof, shall be brought within two years next after the cause of action shall have accrued.
¶7"B. Every action for injury to property, including actions by a parent or guardian of an infant against a tort-feasor for expenses of curing or attempting *180 to cure such infant from the result of a personal injury or loss of services of such infant, shall be brought within five years next after the cause of action shall have accrued." Acts 1977, ch. 617 at 1088.
¶8Section 8.01-248 provides:
"Personal actions for which no other limitation is specified.ÂEvery personal action, for which no limitation is otherwise prescribed, shall be brought within one year after the right to bring such action has accrued."
¶9Acts 1977, ch. 617 at 1089.[1]
¶10In this action for damages based on fraud, we have the first opportunity to construe in an opinion the foregoing new statutes. The main question is whether the one-year limitation of § 8.01-248 or the five-year limitation of § 8.01-243(B) applies under the facts and circumstances of this case. Also, we must determine when the cause of action accrued.
¶11This action was instituted by the purchasers of a house and lot against the real estate agent with whom the purchasers dealt, the agent's employer, and the building contractor from whom the property was bought and by whom the house was constructed. After a hearing based on stipulated facts which incorporated depositions by reference, the trial court sustained defendants' pleas of the statute of limitations, and we awarded the purchasers an appeal. The builder has not appeared as a party appellee.
¶12On February 28, 1980, Michael S. Pigott and Patricia R. Pigott, his wife, executed a contract to purchase residential property in Roanoke County from Norris & Jones Construction Company, Inc. The purchasers dealt with Edna Moran, a real estate agent employed by Lemon & Lambdon, Inc. The "edge" of the property was on "the dividing line" between Roanoke County and Botetourt County.
¶13The purchasers assert the agent was guilty of constructive fraud because she misrepresented to them that unimproved land in Botetourt County abutting their property to the rear was zoned for residential uses when, in fact, the land was zoned for industrial and commercial uses. (During her deposition, the agent vehemently denied the charges of misrepresentation, but, of course, the allegations are taken as true for the limited purpose of ruling on the pleas.)
¶14"About a week or so" after signing the contract, the purchasers were informed by prospective neighbors that the property abutting the house and lot in question was zoned for use as an industrial park. A "couple of weeks before ... April 23, 1980," Mrs. Pigott informed the agent that she and her husband had learned the abutting property was not zoned residential and that they wished to rescind the sale. On April 22, 1980, the purchasers went to the Clerk's Office of the Circuit Court of Botetourt County and ascertained from the Clerk that since 1976 the abutting land had been zoned for commercial and industrial uses. The real estate transaction was closed on May 23, 1980 and the purchasers took possession of the property.
¶15This action was filed April 17, 1981. In the meantime, commercial development had taken place on the adjacent property. A warehouse had been built 30 feet from the purchasers' property line and another building had been constructed about 200 yards from their property.
¶16Particularizing their damage claim, the purchasers alleged in an amended motion for judgment that they had requested Moran to find them a dwelling "in a completely residential community where they could have quiet enjoyment of a home environment for themselves and their child." The plaintiffs asserted that as the result of the conduct of defendants, plaintiffs (1) suffered "the loss of quiet enjoyment of the property" and (2) sustained financial loss due to "the difference between the value of the land were it abutting residential *181 property and its actual value being abutted to commercially and industrially zoned property."
¶17In sustaining defendant's pleas, the trial court concluded that, because the purchasers' action was in fraud, the one-year limitation of § 8.01-248 governed. The court further decided that the evidence "clearly" established the alleged fraud was discovered during the month of March 1980 and this action filed April 17, 1981 was time-barred.
¶18Upon the main issue, the crucial question is whether this is an "action for injury to property," as that phrase is used in § 8.01-243(B). If so, the five-year limitation governs and the purchasers' suit is timely. If not, the catchall provisions of § 8.01-248 govern and the action is time-barred by the one-year limitation.
¶19During oral argument on appeal, the purchasers conceded that the first prong of their damage claim, the claim for alleged loss of peace and quiet of a completely residential environment, was not for an "injury to property" and agreed that such element of damage was governed by the one-year limitation. Thus, we only address the second prong of their claim, the wrongful act resulting in the alleged diminution in value of the purchasers' property because it abutted land zoned for industrial rather than residential uses. Was this an action for "injury to property" within the meaning of § 8.01-243(B)? We hold it was not.
¶20Prior to 1977, a determination of the applicable period of limitations for damage to property turned upon whether or not the cause of action survived. That determination was necessitated by the interplay of §§ 8-24 and former 64.1-145.[2] Section 64.1-145 permitted the survival of actions for damages to the "estate" of a decedent. This statute, however, was construed to relate only to "direct" injury to property and not "indirect" or "consequential" injury. Compare Mumpower v. City of Bristol, 94 Va. 737, 27 S.E. 581 (1897), and Cover v. Critcher, 143 Va. 357, 130 S.E. 238 (1925), with Trust Co. of Norfolk v. Fletcher, 152 Va. 868, 148 S.E. 785 (1929), and Westover Court Corp. v. Eley, 185 Va. 718, 40 S.E.2d 177 (1946).
¶21The statutes now under consideration are among a number of laws enacted in 1977 which sought to relieve the uncertainty and confusion caused by these earlier statutes and their judge-made corollaries. See Revision of Title 8 of the Code of Virginia, Report of the Virginia Code Commission to the Governor and the General Assembly of Virginia, House Doc. No. 14 (1977), at 69. For further analysis of these problems, see Keepe v. Shell Oil Co., 220 Va. 587, 591-94, 260 S.E.2d 722, 725-27 (1979), and First Va. Bank-Colonial v. Baker, 225 Va. 72, 83-84, 301 S.E.2d 8, 15 (1983), both decided after 1977 but applying pre-1977 law.
¶22Under the new statutory scheme, survivability no longer is germane in determining which statute of limitations applies. Code § 8.01-25 provides that all causes of action survive the death of the plaintiff or defendant. Moreover, the problem of determining direct or indirect injury has been eliminated. Code § 64.1-145 now provides, in part, that: "Any action at law for damages for the ... destruction of, or damage to any estate of or by the decedent, whether such damage be direct or indirect, may be maintained by or against the decedent's personal *182 representative. Any such action shall survive pursuant to § 8.01-25." Now, under the straightforward provisions of § 8.01-243(B), "[e]very" action for "injury to property" is governed by a five-year statute of limitations. As we already have said, this is not an action for "injury to property." Rather, this is a "personal action," under § 8.01-248.
¶23Fraud is a tort. Jefferson Standard Life Ins. Co. v. Hedrick, 181 Va. 824, 833, 27 S.E.2d 198, 202 (1943). The wrongful act is aimed at the person and, when sued upon at law, fraud will support a recovery for financial damage personal to the individual. This is the gist of the plaintiffs' claim. The fraud allegedly committed by the realtor had no impact on the real property itself. The purchasers' land was in the same condition and was available for the same use after the alleged fraud as it was before. The defendants' conduct was directed at the plaintiffs personally and not their property, real or personal. Consequently, the trial court correctly decided the one-year limitation governs an action for fraud.
¶24The court below likewise was correct in determining the cause of action accrued in March 1980 when the purchasers were told by prospective neighbors about the industrial use applicable to the adjacent property. Code § 8.01-249 provides, as pertinent here, that a cause of action for fraud shall be deemed to accrue "when such fraud ... is discovered or by the exercise of due diligence reasonably should have been discovered." Discovery of the alleged fraud manifestly occurred when plaintiffs received the information in March, and not on April 22, 1980, as the plaintiffs argue, when the Clerk of Court confirmed that the information was accurate.
¶25For these reasons, the judgment of the trial court dismissing plaintiffs' action will be
¶26Affirmed.
¶27STEPHENSON, J., dissenting.
¶28STEPHENSON, Justice, dissenting.
¶29With the enactment of Title 8.01 of the Code, the Revisors eliminated the distinction between direct and indirect damage to property. Code § 8.01-228 defines "personal action" as "an action wherein a judgment for money is sought, whether for damage to person or property." (Emphasis added.) Code § 8.01-243 ("Personal action for injury to person or property generally.") provides a two-year limitation period in actions for "personal injuries" and a five-year limitation period in actions for "injury to property."
¶30The majority, without explanation, states, "this is not an action for `injury to property.' Rather this is a `personal action,' under § 8.01-248." I believe, however, that the present case is a personal action for "injury to property," i.e., a diminution in the market value of real estate resulting from an alleged fraudulent misrepresentation. Thus, pursuant to Code § 8.01-243(B), the five-year limitation applies.
¶31In my opinion, the result reached by the majority will give rebirth to the malaise which the Code Revisors sought to eliminate. I, therefore, respectfully dissent.
NOTES
¶32[1] Code § 8.01-228 provides that "the term `personal action' shall include an action wherein a judgment for money is sought, whether for damages to person or property."
¶33[2] Section 8-24 provided, in pertinent part:
¶34"Every action for personal injuries shall be brought within two years next after the right to bring the same shall have accrued. Every personal action, for which no limitation is otherwise prescribed, shall be brought within five years next after the right to bring the same shall have accrued, if it be for a matter of such nature that in case a party die it can be brought by or against his representative; and, if it be for a matter not of such nature, shall be brought within one year next after the right to bring the same shall have accrued...."
¶35Section 64.1-145 provided:
¶36"An action at law for money damages may be maintained by or against a personal representative for the taking or carrying away of any goods or for the waste or destruction of, or damage to, any estate of or by his decedent."
¶37delivered the opinion of the Court.
¶38In 1977, as part of the revision of the general laws of Virginia relating to civil remedies and procedure, the General Assembly enacted Code §§ 8.01-243 and -248, dealing with statutes of limitation. Section 8.01-243 provides:
âPersonal action for injury to person or property generally. â A. Unless otherwise provided by statute, every action for personal injuriĂ©s, whatever the theory of recovery, except as provided in B. hereof, shall be brought within two years next after the cause of action shall have accrued.
âB. Every action for injury to property, including actions by a parent or guardian of an infant against a tort-feasor for expenses of curing or attempting to cure such infant from the result of a personal injury or loss of services of such infant, shall be brought within five years next after the cause of action shall have accrued.â Acts 1977, ch. 617 at 1088.
¶39Section 8.01-248 provides:
âPersonal actions for which no other limitation is specified. â Every personal action, for which no limitation is otherwise *78prescribed, shall be brought within one year after the right to bring such action has accrued.â Acts 1977, ch. 617 at 1089.1
¶40In this action for damages based on fraud, we have the first opportunity to construe in an opinion the foregoing new statutes. The main question is whether the one-year limitation of § 8.01-248 or the five-year limitation of § 8.01-243(B) applies under the facts and circumstances of this case. Also, we must determine when the cause of action accrued.
¶41This action was instituted by the purchasers of a house and lot against the real estate agent with whom the purchasers dealt, the agentâs employer, and the building contractor from whom the property was bought and by whom the house was constructed. After a hearing based on stipulated facts which incorporated depositions by reference, the trial court sustained defendantsâ pleas of the statute of limitations, and we awarded the purchasers an appeal. The builder has not appeared as a party appellee.
¶42On February 28, 1980, Michael S. Pigott and Patricia R. Pigott, his wife, executed a contract to purchase residential property in Roanoke County from Norris & Jones Construction Company, Inc. The purchasers dealt with Edna Moran, a real estate agent employed by Lemon & Lambdon, Inc. The âedgeâ of the property was on âthe dividing lineâ between Roanoke County and Botetourt County.
¶43The purchasers assert the agent was guilty of constructive fraud because she misrepresented to them that unimproved land in Botetourt County abutting their property to the rear was zoned for residential uses when, in fact, the land was zoned for industrial and commercial uses. (During her deposition, the agent vehemently denied the charges of misrepresentation, but, of course, the allegations are taken as true for the limited purpose of ruling on the pleas.)
¶44âAbout a week or soâ after signing the contract, the purchasers were informed by prospective neighbors that the property abutting the house and lot in question was zoned for use as an industrial park. A âcouple of weeks before . . . April 23, 1980,â Mrs. Pigott informed the agent that she and her husband had learned the abutting property was not zoned residential and that they wished to rescind the sale. On April 22, 1980, the purchasers went to the *79Clerkâs Office of the Circuit Court of Botetourt County and ascertained from the Clerk that since 1976 the abutting land had been zoned for commercial and industrial uses. The real estate transaction was closed on May 23, 1980 and the purchasers took possession of the property.
¶45This action was filed April 17, 1981. In the meantime, commercial development had taken place on the adjacent property. A warehouse had been built 30 feet from the purchasersâ property line and another building had been constructed about 200 yards from their property.
¶46Particularizing their damage claim, the purchasers alleged in an amended motion for judgment that they had requested Moran to find them a dwelling âin a completely residential community where they could have quiet enjoyment of a home environment for themselves and their child.â The plaintiffs asserted that as the result of the conduct of defendants, plaintiffs (1) suffered âthe loss of quiet enjoyment of the propertyâ and (2) sustained financial loss due to âthe difference between the value of the land were it abutting residential property and its actual value being abutted to commercially and industrially zoned property.â
¶47In sustaining defendantâs pleas, the trial court concluded that, because the purchasersâ action was in fraud, the one-year limitation of § 8.01-248 governed. The court further decided that the evidence âclearlyâ established the alleged fraud was discovered during the month of March 1980 and this action filed April 17, 1981 was time-barred.
¶48Upon the main issue, the crucial question is whether this is an âaction for injury to property,â as that phrase is used in § 8.01-243(B). If so, the five-year limitation governs and the purchasersâ suit is timely. If not, the catchall provisions of § 8.01-248 govern and the action is time-barred by the one-year limitation.
¶49During oral argument on appeal, the purchasers conceded that the first prong of their damage claim, the claim for alleged loss of peace and quiet of a completely residential environment, was not for an âinjury to propertyâ and agreed that such element of damage was governed by the one-year limitation. Thus, we only address the second prong of their claim, the wrongful act resulting in the alleged diminution in value of the purchasersâ property because it abutted land zoned for industrial rather than residential uses. Was this an action for âinjury to propertyâ within the meaning of § 8.01-243(B)? We hold it was not.
¶50*80Prior to 1977, a determination of the applicable period of limitations for damage to property turned upon whether or not the cause of action survived. That determination was necessitated by the interplay of §§ 8-24 and former 64.1-145.
¶51The statutes now under consideration are among a number of laws enacted in 1977 which sought to relieve the uncertainty and confusion caused by these earlier statutes and their judge-made corollaries. See Revision of Title 8 of the Code of Virginia, Report of the Virginia Code Commission to the Governor and the General Assembly of Virginia, House Doc. No. 14 (1977), at 69. For further analysis of these problems, see Keepe v. Shell Oil Co., 220 Va. 587, 591-94, 260 S.E.2d 722, 725-27 (1979), and First Va. Bank-Colonial v. Baker, 225 Va. 72, 83-84, 301 S.E.2d 8, 15 (1983), both decided after 1977 but applying pre-1977 law.
¶52Under the new statutory scheme, survivability no longer is germane in determining which statute of limitations applies. Code § 8.01-25 provides that all causes of action survive the death of the plaintiff or defendant. Moreover, the problem of determining direct or indirect injury has been eliminated. Code § 64.1-145 now provides, in part, that: âAny action at law for damages for the . . . destruction of, or damage to any estate of or by the decedent, whether such damage be direct or indirect, may be maintained by *81or against the decedentâs personal representative. Any such action shall survive pursuant to § 8.01-25.â Now, under the straightforward provisions of § 8.01-243(B), â[ejveryâ action for âinjury to propertyâ is governed by a five-year statute of limitations. As we already have said, this is not an action for âinjury to property.â Rather, this is a âpersonal action,â under § 8.01-248.
¶53Fraud is a tort. Jefferson Standard Life Ins. Co. v. Hedrick, 181 Va. 824, 833, 27 S.E.2d 198, 202 (1943). The wrongful act is aimed at the person and, when sued upon at law, fraud will support a recovery for financial damage personal to the individual. This is the gist of the plaintiffsâ claim. The fraud allegedly committed by the realtor had no impact on the real property itself. The purchasersâ land was in the same condition and was available for the same use after the alleged fraud as it was before. The defendantsâ conduct was directed at the plaintiffs personally and not their property, real or personal. Consequently, the trial court correctly decided the one-year limitation governs an action for fraud.
¶54The court below likewise was correct in determining the cause of action accrued in March 1980 when the purchasers were told by prospective neighbors about the industrial use applicable to the adjacent property. Code § 8.01-249 provides, as pertinent here, that a cause of action for fraud shall be deemed to accrue âwhen such fraud ... is discovered or by the exercise of due diligence reasonably should have been discovered.â Discovery of the alleged fraud manifestly occurred when plaintiffs received the information in March, and not on April 22, 1980, as the plaintiffs argue, when the Clerk of Court confirmed that the information was accurate.
¶55For these reasons, the judgment of the trial court dismissing plaintiffsâ action will be
¶56 Affirmed.
¶57 Code § 8.01-228 provides that âthe term âpersonal actionâ shall include an action wherein a judgment for money is sought, whether for damages to person or property.â
¶58 Section 8-24 provided, in pertinent part:
âEvery action for personal injuries shall be brought within two years next after the right to bring the same shall have accrued. Every personal action, for which no limitation is otherwise prescribed, shall be brought within five years next after the right to bring the same shall have accrued, if it be for a matter of such nature that in case a party die it can be brought by or against his representative; and, if it be for a matter not of such nature, shall be brought within one year next after the right to bring the same shall have accrued. . . .â
¶59Section 64.1-145 provided:
âAn action at law for money damages may be maintained by or against a personal representative for the taking or carrying away of any goods or for the waste or destruction of, or damage to, any estate of or by his decedent.â
¶60dissenting.
¶61With the enactment of Title 8.01 of the Code, the Revisors eliminated the distinction between direct and indirect damage to property. Code § 8.01-228 defines âpersonal actionâ as âan action wherein a judgment for money is sought, whether for damage to person or property.â (Emphasis added.) Code § 8.01-243 (âPer*82sonal action for injury to person or property generally.â) provides a two-year limitation period in actions for âpersonal injuriesâ and a five-year limitation period in actions for âinjury to property.â The majority, without explanation, states, âthis is not an action for âinjury to property.â Rather this is a âpersonal action,â under § 8.01-248.â I believe, however, that the present case is a personal action for âinjury to property,â i.e., a diminution in the market value of real estate resulting from an alleged fraudulent misrepresentation. Thus, pursuant to Code § 8.01-243(8), the five-year limitation applies.
¶62In my Opinion, the result reached by the majority will give rebirth to the malaise which the Code Revisors sought to eliminate. I, therefore, respectfully dissent.