Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

235 N.C. 391

St. Dennis v. Thomas

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided April 9, 1952

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1952-04-09

Relies on Hawkins v. . Hughes · Murchison National Bank v. Broadhurst · Brown v. . Polk

Decided 1952-04-09

YaleNtiNe, J.

¶1Tbe trial judge was correct in overruling tbe plea in abatement. Brown v. Polk, 201 N.C. 375, 160 S.E. 357.

¶2Tbe parties in tbe two suits are not identical. Tbe causes of action are different, and tbe results sought are dissimilar. Tbe final judgment in tbe prior action instituted by L. W. Tbomas and wife, Editb R. Tbomas, against John St. Dennis and wife, Mignon M. St. Dennis, would not prop*393erly support a plea of res judicata, in tbe present action. Tbis is a crucial test of identity. Hawkins v. Hughes, 87 N.C. 115; 1 C.J. 56; Bank v. Broadhurst, 197 N.C. 365, 148 S.E. 452; Thompson v. Herring, 203 N.C. 112, 164 S.E. 619; Oil Co. v. Fertilizer Co., 204 N.C. 362, 168 S.E. 411.

¶3Nothing was said in tbe cases cited in appellants’ brief wbicb militates against our present position.

¶4Tbe judgment of tbe court below must be

¶5Affirmed.

/235/nc/391 · .json · Public domain