Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

237 Ind. 320

144 N.E.2d 529

Docket No. 0-484.

Harr v. State

HARR v. STATE OF INDIANA.

Indiana Supreme Court

Filed September 11, 1957.

Rehearing Denied November 7, 1957.

Indiana Supreme Court · decided 1957-09-11

Relies on State Ex Rel. Casey v. Murray · Davis v. Pelley · Sweet v. State

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1957-09-11

How this case has been cited

Cited by 17 later decisions — most recently May 1994

17 state decisions

11019571960197019801990decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1*321 William F. Harr, pro se.

¶2PER CURIAM.

¶3It appears from the papers filed herein that appellant is attempting, pro se, to submit an appeal to this court. He has, however, failed to file an assignment of errors and otherwise comply with Rule 2-6 of this court, 1954 Edition. Without a proper assignment of errors no jurisdiction is conferred upon this court and the attempted appeal is, therefore, dismissed. Davis v. Pelley (1952), 230 Ind. 248, 251, 102 N.E.2d 910.

¶4

ON PETITION FOR REHEARING

¶5BOBBITT, J.

¶6On August 16, 1957, appellant filed with the Clerk of this court what he designated an "Appeal from the Fayette Circuit Court. Appellant's Brief."

¶7We treated this proceeding as an attempt to appeal and dismissed the same because of the failure to file an Assignment of Errors. See: Harr v. State (1957), 144 N.E.2d 529.

¶8Subsequently, on October 8, 1957, appellant filed with the Clerk of this court a verified petition which he entitled "Assignment of Errors" and requested us to reconsider our decision in 144 N.E.2d 529, and to grant appellant a hearing in the matter.

¶9If appellant's petition filed on October 8, 1957, were to be considered a petition for rehearing it must be dismissed because it was not filed within the time provided. Rule 2-22 of this court, 1954 Edition.

¶10If such petition — "Assignment of Errors" — could be considered as a proper Assignment of Errors it also must be dismissed because it is not filed within ninety *322 days from the date of the decision as provided by Rules 2-40 and 2-2 of this court, 1954 Edition.

¶11The order from which appellant seeks an appeal is one denying his petition for writ of error coram nobis.

¶12Under the rules of this court the only way to grant appellant an appeal under the circumstances in this case would be to treat the papers and petitions filed by him as an attempt to perfect a belated appeal. However, such appeals are authorized only from judgments of convictions in criminal cases. Acts 1947, ch. 189, § 5, p. 625, being § 9-3305, Burns' 1956 Replacement; Sweet v. State (1948), 226 Ind. 566, 81 N.E.2d 679; Cf: State ex rel. Casey v. Murray (1952), 231 Ind. 74, 106 N.E.2d 911.

¶13We have been unable to find any statutory provision or other authority in Indiana which authorizes a belated appeal from a judgment in an action for writ of error coram nobis.

¶14Since the court is unable to find any authority by which an appeal under the circumstances herein may now be granted, the petition filed by appellant herein on October 8, 1957 must be denied.

¶15Petition denied.

¶16Arterburn, C.J., Emmert, Landis and Achor, JJ., concur.

¶17NOTE. — Reported in 144 N.E.2d 529. Rehearing denied 145 N.E.2d 657.

Per Curiam.

¶18It appears from the papers filed herein that appellant is attempting, pro se, to submit an appeal to this court. He has, however, failed to file an assignment of errors and otherwise comply with Eule 2-6 of this court, 1954 Edition. Without a proper assignment of errors no jurisdiction is conferred upon this court and the attempted appeal is, therefore, dismissed. Davis v. Pelley (1952), 230 Ind. 248, 251, 102 N. E. 2d 910.

¶19On Petition for Rehearing

Bobbitt, J.

¶20On August 16, 1957, appellant filed with the Clerk of this court what he designated an “Appeal from the Fayette Circuit Court. Appellant’s Brief.”

¶21We treated this proceeding as an attempt to appeal and dismissed the same because of the failure to file an Assignment of Errors. See: Harr v. State (1957), 144 N. E. 2d 529.

¶22Subsequently, on October 8, 1957, appellant filed with the Clerk of this court a verified petition which he entitled “Assignment of Errors” and requested us to reconsider our decision in 144 N. E. 2d 529, and to grant appellant a hearing in the matter.

¶23If appellant’s petition filed on October 8, 1957, were to be considered a petition for rehearing it must be dismissed because it was not filed within the time provided. Eule 2-22 of this court, 1954 Edition.

¶24If such petition — “Assignment of Errors” — could be considered as a proper Assignment of Errors it also must be dismissed because it is not filed within ninety *322■days from the date of the decision as provided by Rules 2-40 and 2-2 of this court, 1954 Edition.

¶25The order from which appellant seeks an appeal is one denying his petition for writ of error coram nobis.

¶26Under the rules of this court the only way to grant appellant an appeal under the circumstances in this case would be to treat the papers and petitions filed by him as an attempt to perfect a belated appeal. However, such appeals are authorized only from judgments of convictions in criminal cases. Acts 1947, ch. 189, §5, p. 625, being §9-3305, Burns’ 1956 Replacement; Sweet v. State (1948), 226 Ind. 566, 81 N. E. 2d 679; Cf: State ex rel. Casey v. Murray (1952), 231 Ind. 74, 106 N. E. 2d 911.

¶27We have been unable to find any statutory provision or other authority in Indiana which authorizes a belated appeal from a judgment in an action for writ of error coram nobis.

¶28Since the court is unable to find any authority by which an appeal under the circumstances herein may now be granted, the petition filed by appellant herein on October 8, 1957 must be denied.

¶29Petition denied.

¶30Arterburn, C. J., Emmert, Landis and Achor, JJ., concur.

¶31Note. — Reported in 144 N. E. 2d 529.

¶32Rehearing denied 145 N. E. 2d 657.

/237/ind/320 · .json · Public domain