Childress v. Nordman’s Empirical Analysis
1953
Citation profile
2 federal appellate · 31 state decisions
How this case has been cited
Cited by 39 later decisions — most recently November 2014 · most notably 147 Cal. App. 2d 357 - Stevens v. Marco (1956), Winburn v. Insurance Co. of North America (1985)
2 federal appellate · 31 state decisions
Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.
Relationships
Relies on Estate of Dolbeer · Cofield v. Griffin · Conduitt v. Trentonton Gas & Electric Co. · Hanna v. . Stedman · Beach & Clarridge Co. v. American Steam Gauge & Valve Manufacturing Co.
Most-quoted passages
The sentences later courts lift from this opinion, ranked by how many decisions quote each — the parts of the opinion doing the work. These counts are smaller than the citation total above because most of the 39 citing decisions cite the case generally; a passage count includes only decisions quoting that exact language verbatim.
“that a statement true when made has become false has a duty to disclose the change in conditions”
3 later decisions quote this exact passagee.g. Jones Gg v. The American Tobacco Company · Winfred P. Jones, Irene W. Anthony, Kelly E. Brown, Gracie J. Carroll, R. Allen Carroll, Helen O. Coleman, Percy T. Collins, Velma P. Collins, Blanch M. Chatmon, Mary L. Comer, Richard Courts, Daisy J. Crowder, Ernest C. Dickens, Thelma T. Dickens, Novella M. Durham, Dorothy A. Early, Rhodalia C. Eaton, Jessie W. Ferguson, Thomas P. Garrison, Jr., Henry C. Gwynn, Charlotte R. Harden, Mabel D. Holland, James H. Hopper, Irene W. Huskey, Earleen B. Isley, Wilbert C. Jones, Willie P. Kelly, Annie P. King, Ruth H. Lillard, Joseph Maroney, Frances H. Meeks, Frances C. Oakley, Hazel C. Roach, Robert v. Scott, Godfrey D. Slade, Robert L. Smith, Marjorie B. Smothers, Kenneth C. Southard, Mildred M. Stevens, Charles E. Stone, Oscar W. Underwood, Laverne T. Washburn, Elva W. Williams, George E. Williams, M. Ruth Wright, Joseph Alston, Thomas Baker, James P. Browning, Willie C. Colclough, Louise H. Hall, Mary G. Horton, Omer G. Markham, Lois S. May, Mildred McFarland Charles K. McKinney Thelma Page, Otis R. Pulley, Eleanor M. Ray, Elizabeth E. Stell, George W. Strayhorn, Donald B. Tilley, Jr., Ralph Watkins, Norma Watson, Weldon R. Price, Douglas W. Jordan, Jr., Lillie Odom, Clarence O. Terrell, G.G. Spratt, William P. Neal, Jr., and Elizabeth C. Gaiser, Kenneth A. Hodges v. The American Tobacco Company, and American Brands, Incorporated, Winfred P. Jones, Irene W. Anthony, Kelly E. Brown, Gracie J. Carroll, R. Allen Carroll, Helen O. Coleman, Percy T. Collins, Velma P. Collins, Blanch M. Chatmon, Mary L. Comer, Richard Courts, Daisy J. Crowder, Ernest C. Dickens, Thelma T. Dickens, Novella M. Durham, Dorothy A. Early, Rhodalia C. Eaton, Jessie W. Ferguson, Thomas P. Garrison, Jr., Henry C. Gwynn, Charlotte R. Harden, Mabel D. Holland, James H. Hopper, Irene W. Huskey, Earleen B. Isley, Wilbert C. Jones, Willie P. Kelly, Annie P. King, Ruth H. Lillard, Joseph Maroney, Frances H. Meeks, Frances C. Oakley, Hazel C. Roach, Robert v. Scott, Godfrey D. Slade, Robert L. Smith, Marjorie B. Smothers, Kenneth C. Southard, Mildred M. Stevens, Charles E. Stone, Oscar W. Underwood, Laverne T. Washburn, Elva W. Williams, George E. Williams, M. Ruth Wright, Joseph Alston, Thomas Baker, James P. Browning, Willie C. Colclough, Louise H. Hall, Mary G. Horton, Omer G. Markham, Lois S. May, Mildred McFarland Charles K. McKinney Thelma Page, Otis R. Pulley, Eleanor M. Ray, Elizabeth E. Stell, George W. Strayhorn, Donald B. Tilley, Jr., Ralph Watkins, Norma Watson, Weldon R. Price, Douglas W. Jordan, Jr., Lillie Odom, Clarence O. Terrell, G.G. Spratt, William P. Neal, Jr., and Elizabeth C. Gaiser, Kenneth A. Hodges v. The American Tobacco Company, and American Brands, Incorporated““This being true, the case falls within the purview of the general rule that mere proof of the existence of a condition or state of facts at a given time does not raise an inference or presumption that the same condition or state of facts existed on a former occasion. [Citing numerous cases.] This general rule is based on the sound concept that inferences or presumptions of fact do not ordinarily run backward. [Citing cases.]””
2 later decisions quote this exact passage
How this case has been treated — in progress
Whether each later court followed, distinguished, criticized, or overruled this decision. The treatment classification (task #35) runs highest-cited cases first and lights up here as it reaches this one.