Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

239 Ill. App. 3d 601

606 N.E.2d 818

179 Ill.Dec. 986

Hoem v. Zia

Appellate Court of Illinois

Decided December 31, 1992

Appellate Court of Illinois · decided 1992-12-31

Relies on 350 Ill. App. 405 - Pink v. Dempsey

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1992-12-31

How this case has been cited

Cited by 21 later decisions — most recently January 2013

21 state decisions

110199220002010decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

JUSTICE COOK,

¶1specially concurring:

¶2I concur in the majority opinion except for its resolution of the Dead Man’s Act issue.

¶3Plaintiff’s decedent had a conversation with Dr. Zia on October 31, 1988. Dr. Zia made notes of that conversation, and plaintiff introduced those notes at trial. Introduction of the notes constituted testimony “on behalf of the representative to [the] conversation with the deceased,” as set out in the first exception to the Act (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1989, ch. 110, par. 8—201(a)), and the trial court then properly allowed Dr. Zia to testify to that conversation. Introduction of the notes is not much different from plaintiff’s introduction of a deposition of Dr. Zia discussing the conversation, which would clearly waive the protection of the Act. (Pink v. Dempsey (1953), 350 Ill. App. 405, 113 N.E.2d 334; see also Ill. Rev. Stat. 1989, ch. 110, par. 8—201(b) (admission of decedent’s deposition waives protection of Act).) The majority’s overly technical argument that “an exhibit is not testimony” (239 Ill. App. 3d at 613) is refuted by the Act’s third exception, that “[a]ny testimony competent under Section 8—401 of this Act, is not barred by this Section.” (Emphasis added.) (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1989, ch. 110, par. 8—201(c).) Section 8—401 of the Act allows the admission into evidence of “a book, record, or document of original entries.” (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1989, ch. 110, par. 8—401.) Exhibits are testimony as that language is used in the Act.

¶4The underlying basis for the majority opinion on this point may be the belief that Dr. Zia’s trial testimony, so much at odds with his medical notes, is untruthful. Even if that were the case, the jury can adequately determine credibility by comparing the notes to the testimony. This is not a situation where an adverse party testifies to a conversation with a decedent about which the representative knows nothing. This is a situation where decedent’s representative has evidence of the conversation and seeks to use that evidence. The policy of the Act is “not to disadvantage the living but rather to put the parties on an equal footing.” M. Graham, Cleary & Graham’s Handbook of Illinois Evidence §606.6, at 326 (5th ed. 1990).

/239/illapp3d/601 · .json · Public domain