Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

24 Mass. 141

Holmes v. Drew

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided October 23, 1828

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1828-10-23

<p>To a complaint against a mill-owner for flowing land ten years, the respondent pleads that the complainant ought not to have a jury to estimate any damage against her for damage sustained during a portion of the time, for that before a certain day specified, she was neither the owner nor occupier of the mill or dam. Plea held bad, as not covering the whole complaint, nor showing any reason why the complainant should not have a jury.</p> <p>A mill-owner is not liable under St. 1795, c. 74, (“ for the support and regulation of mills,”) for damage done by flowing before his title commenced.</p>

Decided 1828-10-23

Per Curiam.

¶1The plea is insufficient, because it does not cover the whole complaint. It says the respondent is not liable for damages happening before a certain day ; but if she is liable for the subsequent damages, the complainant has a right to a jury.

¶2We think proper to remark, that we are clearly of opinion that the respondent is not answerable for damage done before she became the owner of the mill-dam.1

¶3 Plea adjudged bad and the case remitted, tyc.

¶4 See Charles v. Monson & Brimwfield Manuf. Co, 17 Pick. 70.

/24/mass/141 · .json · Public domain