Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

241 Ala. 145

3 So.2d 433

Brewer v. State

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided April 17, 1941

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1941-04-17

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently April 1941

1 state decisions

Relies on 30 Ala. App. 218 - Ingram v. State

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1941-04-17

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

BOULDIN, Justice.

¶1 This case was decided on the authority of Murphy Ingram v. State, Ala.App., 3 So.2d 426, and must be reviewed as though that opinion was rendered in this case.

¶2 Count 29 charges the defendant “knowingly took from Johnnie Watson *146 four dollars as his fee for making an' arrest, which service was not actually performed by him, or which was a greater fee than was allowed by law for the said services, or was a fee other than allowed by law for said services rendered by him.”

¶3 In the first place, all these alternatives refer to the $4 taken from Johnnie Watson. The first alternative charges that defendant did not actually perform the service for which this sum was taken; the second, that it was a greater fee than allowed by law for such arrest.

¶4 The third, that this $4 was a fee other than allowed by law for said services rendered. Said services can only refer to the arrest for which the fee was taken. That $4 for making an arrest, one arrest, is greater than allowed by law is true as matter of law; therefore, a fee other than allowed by law.

¶5 Construing the statute, Code of 1923, § 4023, Code 1940, Tit. 14, § 160, the Court of Appeals says:

¶6 “It does not prohibit the taking of fees before it was due to him, or a fee other than allowed by law for said services rendered by him.”

¶7 As applied to Count 29 of this indictment, this holding is erroneous. The statute does penalize taking a fee before the service is actually performed. That is what this indictment charges in.one alternative. Granting the officer may take a fee less in amount than the law allows, this is not taking a fee other than allowed by law, but one within the law.

¶8 Certiorari granted.

All Jjistices concur, KNIGHT, J., not sitting.
/241/ala/145 · .json · Public domain