Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

241 La. 757

131 So.2d 55

State v. Cooper

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided May 29, 1961

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1961-05-29

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently December 1963

4 state decisions

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““Counsel for appellant is apparently under the impression that we should review the evidence taken in the case, which has been included in the transcript, in view of Article 557 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (R.S. 15 :- 557) declaring, in substance, that a new trial shall not be granted in any criminal case by reason of error of any matter of pleading or procedure unless it appears ' * * * after an examination of the entire record, * * * ’ that the error complained of has probably resulted in a miscarriage of justice or constitutes a substantial violation of constitutional or statutory rights of the accused. This, however, is a misapprehension because it assumes that the evidence in a criminal case is part of the record, which it is not unless it is appended to and made part of. a perfected bill of exceptions. State v. Brown, 236 La. 562 , 108 So.2d 233 , citing State v. Gaines, 223 La. 711 , 66 So.2d 618 and authorities therein.” State v. Cooper, 241 La. 757 , 131 So.2d 55 . “It is indisputable, too, that under our law the only means by which the testimony may be reviewed by this court is to have it attached to a motion for a new trial, (LSA-R.S. 15:505, 516, 520) and a bill of exceptions must be reserved to the denial of the motion for a new trial. The bill must have attached thereto the motion and evidence relied upon.” State v. Bueche, 243 La. 160 , 142 So.2d 381 .”

quoted by 1 later decision, including State v. Ford

Relies on State v. Gatlin · State v. Brown · State v. Gaines

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1961-05-29

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

McCALEB, Justice.

¶1Appellant was convicted for the theft of $6,000 in money, the property of Mrs. Maggie Bellue, and sentenced to one year at hard labor in the State Penitentiary. On this appeal it is contended that the State failed to adduced proof of appellant’s intent to deprive Mrs. Bellue permanently of the money he obtained from her — an essential element of theft as defined by Article 67 of the Criminal Code (R.S. 14:-67) — and, consequently, his conviction was unlawful.

¶2This contention may not be considered as it requires an examination of all the evidence taken below (see State v. Gatlin, 241 La. 321, 129 So.2d 4, and cases there cited), which is not properly before us because appellant failed to perfect any bills of exceptions in the case. See State v. McDonald, 218 La. 198, 48 So.2d 797; State v. Dartez, 222 La. 9, 62 So.2d 83; State v. Scott, 227 La. 198, 78 So.2d 832; State v. Perez, 228 La. 796, 84 So.2d 195; State v. Richard, 230 La. 853, 89 So.2d 367 and State v. Bennett, 235 La. 987, 106 So.2d 443.

¶3*56 Counsel for appellant is apparently under the impression that we should review the evidence taken in the case, which has been included in the transcript, in view of Article 557 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (R.S. 15:557) declaring, in substance, that a new trial shall not be granted in any criminal case by reason of error of any matter of pleading or procedure unless it appears “ … after an examination of the entire record, … ” that the error complained of has probably resulted in a miscarriage of justice or constitutes a substantial violation of constitutional or statutory rights of the accused. This, however, is a misapprehension because it assumes that the evidence in a criminal case is part of the record, which it is not unless it is appended to and made part of a perfected bill of exceptions. State v. Brown, 236 La. 562, 108 So.2d 233, citing State v. Gaines, 223 La. 711, 66 So.2d 618 and authorities therein.

¶4As appellant does not claim that there are any defects patent on the face of the record, there appears nothing before us for review.

¶5The conviction and sentence are affirmed.

/241/la/757 · .json · Public domain